RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/trans • … • u/Jenny_MTF42

I don’t know what to do when my parents are generally allies but get defensive when they or people they like say hurtful things about trans identities

My parents are supportive of me being trans and have helped me with accessing HRT and new clothes and using all the right pronouns, and celebrating my transition, but it distresses me because it contradicts the way they get when faced with any criticism.

During a dinner in which several of my parents coworkers and acquaintances were over, one of them mentioned working at a clothing store, and how they’d meet several trans people who’d come into the store, and then another person talked about how their son might be a furry. and then all of them started calling trans people ‘weirdos’ and saying ‘we don’t have anything wrong with their identities, but they need to wake up and face the real world sometime!’ My parents didn’t really push back on the most negative points.

Later when I talked to my parents about how I heard what everyone said and was upset by it, my mum just kept bringing up one point over and over again. ‘Well she said that she was supportive of the trans people that’d come in and she’d help them sort out clothes,’ referring to the acquaintance who worked at the clothing store. She repeated this again and again at each point I tried to make about how hurtful and misinformed a lot of the things her coworkers said were, but she again brought that up as if I wasn’t aware of it. I was aware of it, I heard it when the person said it, it wasn’t what I was upset at and it didn’t change how I felt about everything else they said.

Only when I said ‘maybe the term ‘weirdos,’ isn’t the best,’ did my mum actually slightly relent and say ‘yeah it isn’t the best,’ but only on that point.

Once in the past, when I told my mum I wish I was able to better communicate when she says something unintentionally hurtful or when she defends someone else who said something hurtful, she said ‘well I at least hope you know how much I do for you,’ referring to how she has been generally supportive in my transition and has helped get me clothes and on HRT. But me being hurt with something she says has nothing to do with that, and doesn’t imply ungratefulness at all. I shouldn’t have to mention all she does to bring up when she is hurtful. And she often points to hers or others good intentions, only ever focusing on the intentions, and implicitly placing the onus on me and how I react, as if me being aware of the good intentions would somehow make my reaction unreasonable. She also once said along the lines of ‘you need to think about if you want people to be there for you’ when I once mentioned a hurtful thing my sibling said, which I think is actually kind of a horrific thing, at least the way she said it.

During the dinner, what I would have liked my parents to do would’ve been to just push back on the points being made, maybe say that trans identities are real and valid and not ‘weird’ and that we’re not ‘hiding from the real world.’

I just wish they did, and I wish my mum especially was more open to criticism, but I think she’s possibly narcissistic, not just in this topic but in any critique.

Once we also had an argument about the new pope, she said she was relieved it was Leo and not the other American candidate who was MAGA, and I mentioned he has regressive LGBT views and abortion views, and she just kept mentioning ‘well better than the trump one’ and said ‘can’t I just have a bit of relief about this new pope?!’ When I wasn’t even trying to squish her relief or anything, I was just talking about his issues.

I’ve also gotten angry in arguments before when she hasn’t listened to why I had an issue with things, and then she focused on the anger and said it ‘comes out of nowhere,’ and then she says I should try ‘educating people,’ and I’ve really come to resent the word ‘education’ and the way she says it coming from her, because it always means ‘sugarcoat and handhold my way through issues and never criticize me.’ She’s also afterwards when trying to make a point about my anger mimicked the way she thinks I argue, which is always frustrating and hurtful and kinda childish.

And whenever conversations get heated, my dad eventually comes booming in, like he’s trying to act like a big tough guy, essentially yelling at me to shut up and being overprotective of mum, never letting me have a word in.

— 0