RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/travisandtaylor • … • u/kbrick1

Taylor Swift and Feminism

I'm a staunch feminist. My take on Taylor is that she uses feminism as a tool. When it suits her or shuts people up, she's happy to whip it out. Otherwise, she ignores it.

This has resulted in some positive things, honestly. The music industry is incredibly sexist and problematic. Rich white men have been making money off the backs of young, naïve women and women of color for ages. Women have traditionally had very little power in the industry. Taylor helped bring that to light. Granted, she did it entirely for selfish reasons, but it still resulted in something good.

She has also cast light on the problem with slut shaming, and how there is a double standard for men and women in regards to their dating and sex lives. Is this a real thing? Most definitely. Has she only brought this up when it suits her and she's being slut shamed? Yes. Has she engaged in slut shaming herself? Also yes. Very yes. I'd say this comes off as an incredibly mixed message to young fans as a result, so not sure if this behavior has netted positive for women or not.

Here's where Taylor massively fucks up where feminism is concerned:

1. Intersectionality. This is an approach to feminism that has become increasingly important in feminist circles, research, and advancement. I would argue that intersectionality is what makes someone a 'modern' feminist. Here, Taylor scores a big, fat zero. * She has NEVER used her platform to support women of color, promote women of color, mentor women of color, or even create an inclusive space for them. Her black fans have specifically talked about how her fan spaces and her concerts make them feel uncomfortable and unwelcome. She has NEVER addressed this. She hasn't even addressed her hordes of Swifties who spew racist filth *on her behalf.* Yes, she can write songs that clap back at her fans for not liking her boyfriend, but she can't bring herself to say - HEY, STOP BEING STEAMING PILES OF RACIST TRASH. [She stays absolutely silent](https://www.thedailybeast.com/taylor-swifts-racial-blind-spot). * [Here's some insight into the issues facing Black TS fans, ](https://www.popsugar.com/entertainment/black-taylor-swift-fans-reflect-49264761)but if you search reddit, you'll find a bunch of posts dedicated to this very thing. * Then there's the very valid remark that Nicki Minaj made about the VMAs one year: how women who looked certain ways (white, thin) were praised and given awards for their music videos, while darker, curvier women were left out, in other words, that there are racially-charged beauty standards. Taylor was not named and didn't have to say *anything*, but of course she made it all about her and tweeted back: ''[@NICKIMINAJ](https://twitter.com/NICKIMINAJ) I've done nothing but love & support you. It's unlike you to pit women against each other. Maybe one of the men took your slot." - Taylor Swift (@taylorswift13) [July 21, 2015](https://twitter.com/taylorswift13/status/623616796277506048) . No acknowledgement of the problem whatsoever, just invalidating Nicki and basically telling her to shut up. * She has never once owned up to her enormous heaping of white privilege or the way the media has coddled her because she is white and 'wholesome'-coded. Not once. 2. Promotion/mentoring of women in music. This is one that Taylor claims is important to her. She is, superficially, all about women supporting women. However, Taylor has picked fights with more women than any other celebrity I can think of. She routinely uses her power and success to chop the legs out from under successful new artists, especially female artists. She uses 'girl power' mostly to make other women feel excluded and alienated (Katy Perry, Olivia). She gets a big old D- on this one. She talks a good story, but this part of her 'feminism' is literally only utilized when it's helpful or beneficial to her, and she ultimately has done far more harm than good. 3. Contemporary women's issues. * The big, obvious one is abortion. Taylor made a tweet about this when the Roe v Wade decision was first overturned. She also retweeted a couple of things from Michelle Obama. But that's kind of the end of her 'activism'. This is an incredibly important issue at the moment. It is changing and fluid RIGHT NOW. It is affecting women all over the United States RIGHT NOW. That she is not using her enormous, incomprehensible position of power to talk to every single one of her fans and every single young woman who looks up to her about reproductive freedom is wild to me. She could literally change the course of the upcoming election but she will not. I think this is an example of her doing the bare minimum to avoid criticism (we can't say she did nothing! she issued a tweet the same day a gazillion other musicians and celebrities issued nearly identical tweets!) but ultimately refraining from actual activism because she doesn't want to lose fans. * Similarly, Taylor tours worldwide. She has fans in places where women do not have rights in any modern sense of the word. She could also become informed about these types of issues and work to effectuate change in these places--FOR HER FANS--but she does nothing. She gets another D- here.

I think it's clear that Taylor is not an actual feminist. She is not interested in promoting or working on behalf of women's issues. She does not work to effectuate change in the music industry for anyone but herself. She takes on the mantle of 'feminism' when its convenient and helpful to her, and discards it when it's not.

Having female friends to promote an image of yourself as 'popular' and earning enough money to run a small country does not make someone a feminist. And ultimately, that's who Taylor Swift is - a selfish capitalist who looks out for herself above all else and who only touches on feminist issues when they promote her own interests.

— 0