RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/truegaming • … • u/HappiestIguana

Why lack of difficulty modes can be a good thing: a parable

Imagine two players, Alice and Bob.

Alice is very good at video games, but she doesn't know it. She watches a lot of gaming YouTube where she sees world-class players, and she thinks that is the level that you need to be at to call yourself good at games. She plays a lot of videogames and is really good, but if you asked her, she'd say she's mediocre.

Bob is not very good at video games. He doesn't play a lot, but he enjoys the occasional one, especially if it has a good story. He likes exploring virtual worlds, but he is clumsy with a controller and besides, he has a full time job and a family, he wouldn't have time to develop a lot of skill even if he wanted to.

The difference in skill between them is so great that anything that Alice would consider a fun, fair challenge would be impossible for Bob. And anything Bob considered a fun, fair challenge would be utterly trivial for Alice.

You know where I'm going with this. Sit both of them down in front of Dark Souls.

Alice has a _great_ time. She initially struggles, as everyone does their first time through that game, but she is skilled enough that she is able to rise to the challenge. She realizes, for the first time in her gaming life, that she can beat these super-hard games everyone keeps going on about. She feels that trademark Dark Souls Sense of Accomplishment. She falls in love with Dark Souls, the first game that taught her what she's actually capable of.

Bob gives it an honest try, can't get past the Asylum Demon, and refunds the game.

Now add an easy mode to Dark Souls.

Bob has a good time now. He sets it to easy, because he knows he's not very good at games, and he R1 spams through everything. He has a great time exploring Lordran, seeing the beautiful architechture and reading the item descriptions. He never learns builds or stamina management or good positioning, but he doesn't need to. He likes the game.

And Alice? She has a good time too. She also sets it to easy, because she knows this game has a reputation and she doesn't think she'd be able to ever beat it. She thinks the level design is great and appreciates the lore and art. However, she doesn't see the fuss about the gameplay; she finds every combat encounter absolutely trivial. She barely has to use the Estus Flask and occasionally she even forgets to level. She enjoys the game well enough, but she doesn't fall in love with it. She consumes it and moves on.

This example illustrates how an easy mode in a game can make it worse, even for those who don't need it. There is a type of player who consistently chooses a challenge level that is too low for them, and the only way they'll realize this about themselves, is if a game comes along and forces them to do something really hard, with no easy ways out. Only by breaking the brick wall with their forehead will they realize that they can break brick walls with their forehead, and futhermore that breaking brick walls with your forehead is _fun_, but they will never try to break one if there is any other alternative.

Because there is a fundamental problem of game design here. You _cannot_ make a game that appeals to both Alice and Bob on a mechanical level. If you offer a single difficulty that is right for Bob, it will be trivial for Alice. A single difficulty that is right for Alice will be impossible for Bob. And a choice of difficulties, one right for Alice, one for Bob? Alice will pick the wrong one for her.

A world in which every game is accessible to players of every skill level is a world where Alices never realize what they're capable of, and there are a lot of Alices in the world, I know because I am one. Wings of Vi was the first really hard game I beat, a kaizo platformer in the vein of Celeste. That game does technically offer difficulty options, and in fact it recommends starting with Easy, because Easy is already masochistically hard. My death counter was in the quadruple digits by the end of that game (again, on Easy). Had I played Celeste at that age instead, with its richly-developed assist mode that offers everything from minor adjustments all the way to trivializing the game entirely, I would have used them, but Wings of Vi didn't give me that easy way out, it forced me to engage with it at its level, with no compromises. And thanks to that lack of options, I realized that I could beat hard games, and that I loved them.

There are many varieties of Alice. It doesn't have to be a lack of confidence in her own skill. Maybe Alice doesn't understand why anyone would do a masochistically-hard challenge for fun. She figures there must be something wrong with those people who beat games with extreme handicaps, until she actually experiences that feeling of beating a really hard challenge and realizes why it appeals so much. She'd never seek out such a challenge if there were alternatives, but when forced to do it, she realizes she loves it. Or maybe she doesn't have a lot of time to play so she'll pick easy modes for expediency when available (even if she'd have more fun playing fewer games for longer). Or maybe she is legitimately not very skilled, but is a fast learner and has the potential to be better if she pushes herself.

An uncompromising challenge has its value. It is valuable to the Alices of the world, in all their variaties. It has the tradeoff of alienating the Bobs, but should every game ever made appeal to Bob? That isn't to say Bob doesn't matter. It's also valuable to have games that Bob can enjoy, with carefully-designed difficulty options, but shouldn't there be games for Alice too?

You ever wonder why people who love Dark Souls are often resistant to the idea of an easy mode? In large part, it's because of this. It's because many of them recognize that they are Alices, that if an easy mode had been provided, they would have used it, and robbed themselves of an incredible, unique experience. That is why Dark Souls doesn't need an easy mode. That is why it would be a worse game if it did. And it's why it's a good thing that there are games with the same philosophy in regards to difficulty.

— 0