World design concept: Spirit Lights, Trials, Observatories
I've seen a lot of complaints about shrines here and I get what the complaints are about -- repetitive copy/paste aesthetic, too narrow and short for 'dungeons,' the "it's a currency" complaint, etc. And I'm with you there -- while I didn't *dislike* them I *do* wish for deeper, more involved (not necessarily more *difficult*) challenges and greater variety of 'feel' to them.
At the same time I have to give massive props to Nintendo for the core ideas behind why they exist:
- At their inception, they enabled level designers to play around with new concepts that previously would have been more at home in, say, *Portal* and thus they needed a lot of room to experiment with things. While so many of the ideas ultimately wouldn't mesh well into becoming part of 'proper dungeons' it would have been a huge waste of effort to discard so many ideas -- shrines enabled the neat little concepts to still make it into the game.
- They're a key part of the solution to the "open world routing problem" -- that is, how do you take the rails off and let the player just go explore way off the roads, while still pointing the player in the direction of the objective? And how do you enable the player to have just as interesting of a 'return trip' as the forward trip? Combining shrines as 'points of attraction' with clever use of 'triangles' that slowly unfold what attractive points are visible (and thus hide some of them on the forward trip so they're still available on the return trip) makes it so players feel like they're entirely picking their own adventure, makes it so no two players end up experiencing all the things in the same order, and yet breadcrumbs players into going the 'right' direction without having to give them dotted lines or map markers to follow.
With that in mind I present new concepts that I would *hope* can resolve some of the issues with shrines, while still solving the fundamental problems that shrines were created to solve.
____________________________
Concept: **Spirit Lights**
Visible from a great distance, their appearance is an ethereal glowing thing resembling a lamp post, with the glow changing to a more subdued color and brightness when completed, thus serving as a point of attraction.
Upon activation, it serves as a fast travel point, much like a shrine, but rather than being something that you enter, it issues a short challenge right there in the place that you are. These challenges are on the scale of the shorter shrines or even more complicated Korok puzzles -- reach the destination, place the object, hit the target, etc. All of them are timed. Many of them spawn in elements related to the challenge, i.e. pillars, walls, balls, switches, mechanisms, terrain, goal markers, etc. which appear as transparent glowy outlines of stuff.
While simply reaching the point activates the fast-travel point, receiving the reward for it requires completion of the challenge -- and with game design that spreads out obtaining of core abilities across story progress, *you may not be able to complete a given challenge in your current state, requiring you to return later.* After you fail a challenge, a message will appear stating such.
The reward for completing a Spirit Light challenge is a Spirit Light Fragment, which a certain number of them (4 seems pretty standard) will automatically combine to expand your Magic Vial (functionally comparable to TotK's Energy Cells, though it's used for operating many of your core abilities instead of powering vehicles).
_____________________________
Concept: **Trials**
Unlike Spirit Lights, *Trials* are a more involved concept. They can be stumbled on by pure exploration but are not intended directly as high-visibility points of attraction. Instead:
- All of them can be found via side quests, i.e. NPCs talking about interesting stuff they found, but are also possible to just stumble upon.
- All of them require some kind of extra attention to activate. The way to them may not open without use of key required equipment, i.e. Magic Rope, Roc's Cape, Staff of Dominion, Empowering Gauntlet, etc. which puzzle serves as a sort of 'equipment check' to make sure you have the necessary stuff to complete it.
- Trials themselves occur in alt-space much like the last game's shrines.
- Trials limit you in some way relevant to the reward -- i.e. a combat trial will limit you to three hearts and reward you with a full heart container, a feats trial will limit you to one wheel of stamina and reward you with a full stamina vessel, and puzzle-y trials limit your equipment/abilities and reward you with some sort of notable upgrade to them (swim speed, glide mobility, climb speed, stronger element boost...)
- Level design resembles more "Donkey Kong" formula rather than "Mario" formula -- that is, they begin by introducing a concept and exploring it, then transition to a separate concept and exploring it, then finishing off by combining the two concepts in a new way that challenges your understanding of both. Essentially they're as long and complex as perhaps three shrines put together.
__________________________
I'm still thinking about the "towers" problem. I feel that Tears of the Kingdom substantially improved on BotW's towers by having each tower have a unique problem to solve before getting the rewards of both map data and high place wherewith to pick new points of interest to move toward, but even so the concept still needs something.
My first impression is to make the 'towers' correspond to more interesting content. One idea is to connect them to laboratories where you can purchase upgrades to equipment or unique items. And while I'm not a fan of towers populating your map with locations of all the secret junk, I think it wouldn't be a terrible idea for there to be an additional quest to enable such functionality and additional cost to have the people at the lab reveal the locations of hidden stuff for you -- it's just something you have to opt into and work for if you have completionist impulses.
___________________
So there you have it. Discuss:
- Do you feel that these ideas, in conjunction with other content i.e. spreading out core abilities, better dungeons, etc., resolves the primary issues with shrines?
- Do these cause *new* issues that shrines had already solved, and these 'un-solve?'
- Ideas for any of these that sound like they'd be fun and interesting challenges?
- Alternative ideas on solving the 'open world problem' if you've got a better concept?