[All] New headcanon and fan theory about the purpose and difference of Hylians from normal humans.
So before I put the idea down, a few things to preface this with.
Hyruleans: - Anyone who lives in the Kingdom of Hyrule, this includes the Gorons, Zoras, Hylians, Humans, sometimes Gerudo, though the Gorons, Zoras, and Gerudo may sometimes have their own kingdoms that the give allegiance to and are only allied with the Kingdom of Hyrule. Incidentally during the Hyrulean Civil War, all the above races seemed to take part.
Hylians: - This is the race of pointy eared humans that seem to be a large part of the population and entirely compose the royal family.
Next, given that at the height of Hyrule’s power, the somewhat misnamed Castle Town was likely a bustling metropolis. It stands to reason that an equivalent time period metropolis would have been fed by about 4-5 other large cities about 30-50 towns and approximately 1500 villages. That would give it a rough population in the ballpark of 800,000 peoples. And I’m not going to give the math of this but I did this calculation too, but the area of the Kingdom of Hyrule is likely around 40,000 km^2.
Lastly, there is a semi well known theory that Rupees are crystallized light magic. A few points from that theory is that the currency doesn’t appear to work like normal additive and subtractive coinage currencies. Also, the fact that you can open a chest and get negative money seems to jive with the idea of being hit with a kind of negative magic energy which is mitigated by rupees. With coinage, you can’t open a chest and acquire debt like that normally. And lastly, the great fairies in BotW, notable light magic beings, ask for rupees to replenish their power. Seems reasonable that they might be converting it back into pure light magic to rejuvenate themselves.
So given that, I was thinking about the Kingdom of Hyrule last night and what the civil war aftermath would be like. Imagine OoT Link stepping foot onto Hyrule field for the first time, realistically what would he have seen?
Probably hundreds of villages, farming communities dotted all over. But the destruction would have been rampant. Some villages burnt out husks, populated only by territorial poes, farms understaffed or run by prodominantly women (no hate, just comparing to Europe where the male population tended to make up the bulk of the armies) and the elderly. Some, probably many of these villages would be suffering from lack of food, or illness. Military outposts will be placed possibly frequently but in various states of ruin with the stonework replaced by temporary wood work trying to keep the peace.
Realistically, Link is making his way to the castle to speak with Zelda but he’s going to be hitting up these places along the way and helping out. Essentially doing what Gandalf did for middle earth with Narya.
That got me thinking though. This kingdom has magic, there would be churches and healers in places, if rupees are light magic, they would likely be used in the process of healing others or protecting them: we see this to some degree with the magic armor.
But post civil war, what’s going to happen? Lots of instability, power struggles, etc. but Hyrule is kind of known for surviving despite the calamities. So how does the king maintain control of all these struggling lands? What’s he doing? Why don’t the people despise him? Or revolt against him in a post civil war society where the king literally can’t help everyone? Especially when the nobles are going to be the wealthiest and therefore most likely to survive while the poor suffer.
And that brings me to the distinction between humans and Hylians. I suspect that the Hylians are more prone to virtuous traits. These traits naturally accumulate additional light magic, but that’s also the currency. So the most noble, magnanimous, loyal, and best suited to wield power in a generous way also tend to be the ones that naturally come into power due to both biology and economy.
But also after something like a war, leaders are going to lead, the nobility are also the most likely to perish. So in a post civil war Hyrulean society, people may still hold allegiance to fallen Bible houses and the kingdom due to how people cling to those that lift them up. And the King or Queen of Hyrule is held in particularly high regard for that. Thus the kingdom pushed on and tends to recover more quickly than a typical human kingdom might.