RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/turntables • … • u/CurinDerwin

VPI Player turntable has a disappointing (to me) soundstage width compared to a table 1/10th the price.

I upgraded to a VPI Player from an Audio-Technica AT-LP120XUSB-BK.

Standard AT cartridge on the LP1, VPI/AT Shirley cartridge on the VPI Player.

The VPI Player, initially, sounded muddy out of the box. The mids were lacking all wrong and the bass was much too loud. Over time this subsided. It is now over a month and a half of burn-in and while I can definitely tell the VPI is better at distinguishing between instruments and sounds, the soundstage "width" of the music is narrower, the volume is quieter than the AT LP1 and, honestly? I don't find myself tapping or enjoying the music experience on the VPI as much as I can with the AT. The feedback and vibration, however, is much more easily managed on the VPI. Huge plus.

Comparison has been exhausting. and each time I prefer the LP1. I think to myself "If only the player were louder and had a wider soundstage, I'd be all set.

I'm at a loss. Is this the cartridge? Maybe the Phono Pre difference?

All cables, grounds, and speakers are the same.

— 0