RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/tvshow • … • u/Ok_Palpitation_3742

Rory Gilmore wasn’t a particularly good kid. She was decent at best.

I’ve been rewatching Gilmore Girls and something that bothers me is how Rory is constantly portrayed as this exceptionally good, responsible and thoughtful kid. But was she really?

I’m not saying Rory was a terrible person but I think she was decent at best. A lot of her behavior gets overlooked because she’s quiet, academically successful and generally polite.

Take her friendship with Lane. When Rory started dating Dean, she became so caught up in her relationship that she wasn’t really there for Lane when Lane needed her. Lane even had to confront her about it. Considering how restrictive Lane’s home life was and how much she relied on Rory as her closest friend, I thought that was pretty inconsiderate.

Then there’s how she treated Dean when she started developing feelings for Jess. She clearly liked Jess but continued dating Dean instead of being honest with him or herself. She even kissed Jess while she was still with Dean. Being confused about your feelings is understandable but stringing someone along isn’t fair.

And then there’s Lindsay. Rory knew Dean was married, yet she still got involved with him. What bothered me even more was how she initially justified it by saying he was "her Dean". She had also been pretty dismissive of Lindsay before the affair. I understand that Dean was equally responsible for his marriage but Rory wasn’t an innocent bystander either.

Then there’s the time Rory ran away to her grandparents’ house after an argument with Lorelai. She didn’t bother telling her mother where she was or making sure Lorelai knew she was safe. Emily had to call Lorelai herself. I understand teenagers argue with their parents but disappearing without communicating was inconsiderate.

And later, when Rory decided to leave Yale, she moved in with her grandparents because Lorelai wouldn’t support her decision. Taking time off college isn’t inherently wrong but instead of working through a difficult disagreement with her mother, she essentially cut her off for months. Lorelai wasn’t perfect in that situation either but Rory’s handling of it wasn’t particularly mature.

What bothers me isn’t that Rory made mistakes. Everyone does, especially when they’re young. It’s that the show spends so much time establishing her as this exceptionally good kid when she could actually be quite selfish, avoidant and inconsiderate of the people closest to her.

Being academically successful, well-spoken and relatively well-behaved doesn’t automatically make someone a particularly good person.

I think Rory was a decent kid who had plenty of good qualities but she was nowhere near as exceptional as everyone around her seemed to believe.

Sometimes I wonder whether constantly being told she was special and could do no wrong contributed to some of her behavior.

Does anyone else feel like Rory’s reputation as the "good kid" had more to do with how she appeared to others than how she actually treated people?

— 0