Character gives an absolutely insane (but true) explanation, instead of an EASILY believable lie
I’m currently watching a horror movie where there’s like a cult or demon something conspiring to kill people in a nursing home. The woman, at every turn, insists on telling her family that there’s demon or monsters or whatever, rather than just making up such an easily believable lie that would resolve the situation without calling her sanity into question. “I don’t like how they treat me here” would completely solve the issue and get her out, but instead she thinks her best bet is to convince people that demons are real.
It doesn’t even have to be a lie, just any explanation that’s easier to swallow than “ghosts are real, aliens too, the earth is flat, and that’s why we need to leave” instead of “this place sucks let’s go”
EDIT: I found it, the trope is called “you have to believe me”