RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/twentyonepilots • … • u/poptivist

a connection i think we missed on dmaorg and the color pink

kind of a roundabout approach here but bear with me.

So here are some lyrics to Morph, and bolded underneath is how I interpret them.

​

>lights they blink to me, transmitting things to me > >**ideas are being broadcast to me** > >ones and zeroes, ergo this symphony > >**binary ideas: hence me writing this music** > >anybody listening? ones and zeros > >**pay attention. ones and zeros.** > >count to infinity, ones and zeroes > >**an unrealistic thing. ones and zeros**

so it occurred to me hey, maybe google that.

​

![img](7u0fm7m0rzy61)

so to me that amounts to:

1. ones and zeros are binary code 2. one three times (111) and zero three times (000) is binary code for white and black 3. absolutes = an unrealistic thing (you can't count to infinity).

I understand that some people are dubious of the idea that tyler would include something like a reference to color in his lyrics, but I would offer this as a supporting statement:

​

![img](nnw3pap8rzy61)

given the current branding, i think it's fair to say looking at the lyrics from that angle held water.

![img](pfdjv3lbrzy61)

See also: “still not sure if fear’s a rival or close relative to truth.” In the context of Trench, the only available rival is Nico, whose color is red. That would make truth, the close relative, pink. (Subjective truth, not objective truth.) For example:

​

![img](nw38a3jutzy61)

Josh, right when he got his pink icon, was for a while just going around saying [things](https://twitter.com/joshuadun/status/1382096177445937153?s=20) [he believes](https://twitter.com/joshuadun/status/1382559001523712000?s=20) [are true](https://twitter.com/joshuadun/status/1383896591442931715?s=20). (that last one: jordan had just posted an insta story where he was in fact listening to shy away on the radio.)

​

![img](j586rluztzy61)

Not [all](https://twitter.com/joshuadun/status/1386084698644955139?s=20) of them [are](https://twitter.com/joshuadun/status/1387102056448765959?s=20) true. What we believe is sometimes not quite accurate (again, sorry Josh) or [distorted](https://twitter.com/joshuadun/status/1382561042581094402?s=20) by [memory](https://twitter.com/joshuadun/status/1391197409397592075?s=20). For comparison, the half-hearted tone of [this tweet](https://twitter.com/joshuadun/status/1339314150376398851?s=20) and desaturated, pale pink shirt says he didn’t really believe what he was saying.

Literally seconds after I was looking up what the pantone equivalent of “mulberry” would be and had tweeted it, a friend posted this crop of a fan photo josh had just been in:

​

![img](k0bze9g3uzy61)

It seems reasonable to conclude that if mulberry is conviction, intense belief, and pale pink is noncommittal belief, a flexible middleground would be a nice rosie color.

There’s a lot of fun color stuff to talk about imo but getting back to my point: each of the dmaorg files included in its design some implicit instruction as to its handling: the cheetah gif with a letter on each frame so that we knew we should write down the letters and arrange them into something sensible, and so on. File names contained information too, like \_they\_ca\_ntseeFCE300. \[[link if you wanna reread](https://web.archive.org/web/20200305053735/http://dmaorg.info/found/15398642_14/clancy.html)\]

I think we maybe dropped the ball a little with [this one](https://web.archive.org/web/20200131090536im_/http://dmaorg.info/found/15398642_14/img/d65d2dbd7e18/_e_sr__eve_r_.jpg) and [this one](https://web.archive.org/web/20200305053735im_/http://dmaorg.info/found/15398642_14/img/8eba5cff5d62/_note.gif).

I think we were meant to invert them both. The first one because the file name is \_e\_sr\_\_eve\_r\_,but spelled in reverse, so some less immediately obvious kind of reversal is being suggested, and reading the sentences backwards makes no difference. t

The second because it's shown to be the back of the inverted image of tyler lying in the stream. You can't do anything else with it. And we’re not looking at just an image, but an image of an actual piece of paper. You can see that it's ripped across the surface, too, showing the color on the other side, suggesting this is a singular object. Ergo if you could actually invert a piece of paper, inverting one side would invert the other.

![video](zawejy5qvzy61)

Upon doing so, we suddenly have a pattern with the third black letter, and their similarities become clear: this is clancy speaking in absolute terms.

![img](gc8u57ivvzy61)

Two of these say “they’re asleep.” One particularly emphatic paragraph says:

>“They are asleep. They’re so sure that they know the truth, and carry on throughout their day with the same meaningless tasks. They’ve forgotten to look up, and to look outward, to understand that this isn’t about ‘in there.’ This is about ‘out here.’ “

In car radio, faith is to be awake and the opposite is to be asleep. In this scenario it’s the “faithful” (to the religion of vialism) who are asleep. Neither reduction to a simple binary serves us.

In each of the white letters, clancy expresses some measure of uncertainty: in the first, calling Dema a trap, but still recalling it in positive terms; the second, “This hope of discovery alone has birthed a new version of myself; A better version, I hope…”; in the sixth, “I’m still trying to understand.” In the seventh, “There is still so much I do not understand.”

Compare this to the language of the black letters: the “trap” of his first letter becomes a “rigid tomb.” He says the bishops have “extinguished the hope that once motivated our existence.” He calls the inhabitants of Dema “mindlessly obedient”, “devoid of any trace of identity.” He says “they’re so sure that they know the truth” -- as if he himself is a position to say objectively that they’re wrong. That’s...pretty dogmatic, and playing right into vialism’s hands, in a way.

In the live show, dema is always [depicted in greyscale](https://youtu.be/XwNRw59d3EI), total desaturation, and we see fewer colors on screen as we approach it in a given set of show visuals. Sometimes we never leave the greyscale to begin with, like car radio visuals. Which makes sense, because car radio offers us a binary: you’re either asleep or have faith, no in between. (How different is a vial from a vessel? They might be opposites, but maybe it just depends on the angle you’re looking at it from.)

If you went true east indefinitely, you'd end up back where you started. And Clancy does, and tyler does. If it's all about jurisdiction, based on the way tyler keeps getting captured, trench is demonstrably still in that jurisdiction. It may be that completely severing ties with where you come from and going as hard as possible in the other direction over and over isn't much more liberated than the static structure you escaped. Ultimately Clancy pushes himself hard enough that he *chooses* to go back.

I think Clancy is a representation of tyler's faith (not my idea, but i can't remember for the life of me who said it to me. Someone on twitter.) I don't think he's meant to be an example for us to follow, just a demonstration of the struggle of swinging between lost uncertainty, knowing you're in the wrong place, and total certainty that you have the answer and everyone else is asleep. That struggle lasts a lifetime, which I think explains the date range of the letters, and the fact that "sai/psi is propaganda" was shown in a picture of tyler and josh as kids. It's always been there. (but just because it's written in pink doesn't make it the truth, just maybe a truth, and there's no guarantee it isn't basically indistinguishable from a fear (red).

![img](cplj8jg4xzy61)

![img](tfodxx1twzy61)

In previous cycles, the logo demonstrated a struggle: red vs blue, red vs white, but then we get to yellow vs yellow. In the yellow double bars logo, both sides of the [dash](https://www.instagram.com/p/ie3NFSlutO/) are ultimately the same choice, not opposed ones. They lead back to the same place.||=//

(edited to include this visual, which would be helpful: i'm pretty sure the circle has always been the city.)

![img](p7xfrjnp10z61)

So I think if turning the map gave us a desaturated (and infuriatingly grainy) view of the world, like turning down a dial, the SAI version shows the saturated version (and both mvs so far are available in a sharply detailed 4k). Whether it’s too saturated remains to be seen.

![img](w2s09szaxzy61)

In any case this is super long and if it even lets me post i'm not sure anyone's gonna read this far but if you do, this is my first post, please don't eat me. i'd love to hear your thoughts.

— 0