Edward’s comment in midnight sun
At the family meeting in midnight sun, I don’t really love Edward’s comment “we know what a perfect assassin you are” towards Rosalie. Now, I get that he was stressed and worried, but I found it not only insensitive but also hypocritical, considering he has a history of a killing spree. He also said it in front of the whole family. One could argue that Rosalie brought it up first by saying “you know I am capable of control and won’t leave evidence behind”, but she brings it up without getting into her personal trauma history and Edward has to add that jab. I liked how Carlisle shut him down. If anything, I think it is a good reminder that he is mentally 17, but it wasn’t his finest moment. Sometimes people put him on a pedestal, but he’s not perfect. That doesn’t mean he’s a bad person, but just shows he isn’t always perfect in what he says and does.