The history of Mike and Bob
I’ve been rewatching from the start, just watched Ep16, so there might be some simple answers to some of my questions from elsewhere which I’ve forgotten - but I have seen everything so don’t mind responses with spoilers for FWWM, The Return etc.
I did a search and found some of these questions posted before but a long time ago and without much discussion.
I’m pondering the history of Bob, and in particular when he and Mike were killing together. Here are my thoughts:
\- Leland was born around 1940? And Bob first possessed him as a young child, so likely in the 1940s.
\- Mike is possessing Philip Gerard, and since he felt the need to cut off his arm then it was this body he possessed when doing killing. I’m not 100% on this, it was the tattoo he wanted to remove, it could well be that he changed bodies post-killing but still had the tattoo which may have magically transferred.
\- If it was when PG was possessed, then this implies that this killing happened during Leland’s lifetime, so either Bob was in Leland’s body, or was able to leave it and later return.
\- The feeling when PG is helping to track Bob is that it is because he can see his true face, not because he is possessing the same guy he knew (though also I understand that a scene in FWWM may confuse this more).
\- I think that the idea that Bob could have left Leland for a time is worth considering. It ties in with the question of, why is Leland suddenly killing people around 1988-89, how was he contained before that. I would theorise that Bob's evil was satisfied by the abuse of Laura, and things only escalated as she was getting to the age that she would get away from him (and also when he saw that she was with other men). In a similar way, Bob would have abused Leland as a child, but there is then a large gap from Leland become an adult to when Laura was around as the next target. It is possible that during this time Bob was somehow able to separate from Leland and carry out the killings with Mike, before returning to Leland when the time was right. Perhaps this is related to the relationship of Bob as Mike’s “familiar”, perhaps he needed this somehow to be able to do this without letting go of Leland.
\- Another question of Bob’s history is who he inhabited before Leland. I have wondered if it was actually Leland’s grandfather. The white house nearby could have been a vacant house where Leland’s grandfather appeared to him as Bob. Perhaps this is a common understanding. I’ve also wondered about the fact that Bob turns very violent when ready to leave Leland - not just with the murders, but the recklessness - over time his story of dropping off Maddy at the bus station would be proven to be a lie, but then also he looks ready to attack Cooper in broad daylight with the sheriff as witness! Did this sort of thing happen when he left the body before Leland? I suspect not, I think it happened in the show because Laura did not accept him.