My Theory on Judy, Sarah, Laura, Jumping Man, Chalfonts, and More!
TL;DR: Judy is Laura/Laura's doppelganger/Laura's pain haunting Sarah.
Below are quite a few pieces of thread about who Judy might be. It involves some information most of you will probably know, but also contains some insights and connections I've made.
We hear Mr. C talking to someone impersonating Jeffries. The person on the other end of the line has Sarah Palmer's voice. And she says, "I missed you in New York". We know that the Experiment and Cooper arrived in the glass box moments apart. The Experiment missed Cooper in New York. If Judy is the creature that was named as "The Experiment" in the credits, then that lends credit to the theory that says Sarah is inhabited by Judy. But this would require us to take the (small) leap of associating the Experiment with Judy. A small step, because we saw the Experiment spew out BOB, and she looks a lot like an extreme negative force. (In some frames, when the Experiment is attacking Sam and Tracy, it looks like Leland's anguished white face, but I might be imagining things. I'll put the screenshot here because it's interesting.)






\- The Experiment (we'll assume it's Jowday/Judy) has bent back arms. Remember Laura in the Lodge saying, "I feel like I know her, but sometimes, my arms bend back."

Linking Sarah to Judy requires us linking Judy to the Jumping Man and the Tremonds/Chalfonts. Sarah's face is superimposed on the Jumping Man. But this linking is somewhat straightforward since Jowday attacks with a sharp, needle-like protrusion, which looks a lot like Jumping Man's nose, the protrusion on the mask of Pierre Tremond/Chalfont. The Experiment killed Sam and Tracy with this needle. Pierre points his finger (like the pointy nose of murder) towards BOB and says, "Fell a victim", like ordaining BOB to kill Laura.





The black smile Sarah shows is eerily similar to Laura's smile. It's probably a reworked version of the smile on Laura's face in her homecoming photo. But Laura shows an ominous smile herself, under the ceiling fan in FWWM, and we have a lengthier version of it in the Missing Pieces.



And the hand she shows is a left hand with a blackened and swollen ring finger. This is the finger Laura put the ring on, and that finger is the "spiritual mound" which allowed Cole to determine Mr. C was Cooper's doppelganger. Also, the smile we see is another link to the Jumping Man (FWWM keeps zooming in on the Jumping Man's toothy grin). If the "Experiment" is indeed Judy, this would prove a connection between Judy and the Jumping Man/Tremonds/Chalfonts, as well as Laura and Sarah.


\- The appearance of the White Horse. Sarah sees the white horse when she's drugged by Leland and is unaware of the assault on Laura. White Horse is also quite prominent in the last episode. Carrie Page has a white horse figurine on the mantle. There's a white horse toy in front of Judy's Diner. The white horse may symbolize Sarah's ignorance of what was happening to Laura, and the pain and guilt she felt and let fester for 25 years. Also, the Woodsman's broadcast includes the "white horse," which caused Sarah, as a little girl, to pass out and be "unaware." What Carrie Page hears is Sarah calling out her name (Laura, Laura) when she didn't know (was ignorant of) her daughter's death. Carrie remembers being Laura (her pain) and realizes the pain Sarah went through, and they're reconciled, ending the dream. 2 birds with 1 stone.



The diner is the only piece of concrete information that links this world to Judy. But we don't see Sarah in this world; we only hear her voice. However, we do see Laura (as Carrie Page), who worked at Judy's. Remember what Jeffries said, "I found something in Seattle at Judy's." (Josie frequently went to Seattle, but this Judy's is in Odessa, TX).
Cooper gives Jeffries the date Laura Palmer was murdered, and Jeffries replies with "This is where you'll find Judy." And he's transported to where Laura is, in 1989. Right after Jeffries says it, the camera closes in on Cooper's face, like information was transmitted, maybe it's the knowledge of Judy being Laura. Jeffries gives this information to Cooper, but doesn't give it to Mr. C. Does giving Cooper this information also mean he gave this information to Mr. C, who's still a part of Cooper? And the crucial point: BOB was obsessed with Laura, like Mr. C was obsessed with Judy. Mr. C's obsession with Judy is like a perverted mirror of Cooper's investigation of Laura. This would allow us to draw some sort of parallel like Cooper - Laura // Cooper's doppelganger (Mr. C/BOB) - Laura's doppelganger (Judy).
To me, the cleanest way to connect all these is to exclaim, Judy is Laura's doppelganger, haunting Sarah. I don't know how or why the Jumping Man or Chalfonts are related, but the connection is unmistakable.
\----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
**Edit:** user u/Feisty_Ease_1983 shared their doubts, which led me to write more about **what** Judy is, as opposed to **who** Judy is. Here is what I wrote on the matter:
# I've talked mostly about who Judy is; now, let me clarify what Judy is.
**Note**: I'll refer to different representations of the same thing as **Jowday** and **Judy** in this, just to clarify which aspect I'm talking about; **I'm not suggesting that these names are used differently for this purpose by Lynch/Frost.**
Twin Peaks is Laura's **dream**, but we **never** see **Laura the dreamer**. The Laura we see is only **her avatar**, her ego, the **part of her that experiences life**. Everything else represents other aspects of Laura, her life, her experiences, her conscious and unconscious reality.
**Jowday** is the unspeakable, primordial horror. It is an **outside force** that forced its way into Laura and her dream, through the abuse she endured. However, we are not able to see anything that's not part of Laura's dream. So, **we don't see the true face of Jowday** (it probably doesn't have a face). The **Judy** that we see, or "the experiment," is how this horror manifests itself in Laura's dream. The source of the horror, the evil, is in the **real world** (the world that contains Laura's dream).
BOB is Laura's representation of the evil that men do. Judy is the representation of Jowday, the capital E Evil. But those are still how Laura's psyche copes with what happened. It's a reality where fathers can abuse daughters.
Notice how I said Judy is Laura's **doppelganger**/Laura's **pain**. Not Laura herself. What I wrote in the "TL;DR" section is an allusion to the fact that the doppelganger is still part of the person, even though it's the repressed part. When I say Judy is Laura's doppelganger/Laura's pain, I mean that it's the part of her that was invaded by Evil, it's the part of her that suffered, was hurt, was corrupted, and became a vessel of Jowday. Evil left its mark in Laura. Judy is Jowday in Twin Peaks. We see her when she says things like "Your Laura disappeared, it's just me now."
When I say she was "invaded by Evil", it is mirrored in Sarah swallowing the frog-moth. Young children who do not have the capacity to understand evil just consume the evil directly. It leaves a lasting mark in them, and it continues living in them. Consider babies who put everything in their mouths to understand something.
So, Judy is not literally Laura, the high school homecoming queen, which is an avatar, but it's the counter to the homecoming queen. It's the evil that lives within Laura. The Fireman created the pure soul of Laura out of his own soul to counteract this primordial horror. This pure soul is capable of enduring what happened to her. She chose death rather than to be shaped by it. **Sarah didn't have the same constitution.** Laura's pain destroyed Sarah, turned her into a crazed lady who smokes, drinks, sits in the dark, and wails. She became something that everyone is afraid of.
After Laura died, she was saved. Her guardian angel returned. But Twin Peaks had to keep on living with the pain Laura endured. Laura moved on, but the memory is retained in the town.
Note: Even if you disregard my assumption that Laura is the dreamer, this theory still makes sense. Judy would still be the pain she endured. The pain she lived through and the town doing nothing to stop it shook Twin Peaks to its core; it lived on, causing the town to rot within.
\----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
**Edit 2**:
# A bit more about Chalfonts/Tremonds/The Ring and what the end of season 3 means
I see the Chalfonts as being the opposite of the White Horse. The white horse symbolizes unawareness/ignorance, while Mrs. Chalfont/Tremond and Pierre represent awakening/discovery.
**The Picture Frame**
* Mrs. Chalfont gave Laura the picture frame that shows the inside of the Black Lodge, and there, Pierre warned Laura: "The man behind the mask is looking for the book with the pages torn out. He's under the fan now." Here, Mrs. Chalfont and Pierre are revelatory. They cause Laura to go home, and once there, she finally learns who BOB really is. She sees BOB in her room and runs outside, hides under the bush. Then, she sees her father, but goes into denial. She cries, "It's not him." They made the first push into realization, and it will continue in her dreams. * Laura puts the frame in her room and goes to sleep. She has a dream in which she sees Mrs. Chalfont and Pierre in the convenience store entrance (the entrance the entities use) to the black lodge. Mrs. Chalfont points the way towards the black lodge, and Pierre snaps his fingers, invoking fire (this is the Fire Walk With Me ritual). Pierre, snapping his fingers, opens the door to the black lodge (her unconscious). She then saw Mike offering her the ring (the ultimate tool of awakening by submersion in the dark), and Cooper warning her not to take the ring. After that, she goes deeper by waking up to another dream and finds Annie by her side and the ring in her hand, but the picture wasn't done showing her. * She gets up, goes near the frame, and we can hear Sarah's voice calling "Laura" as she did on the morning she was found dead (this exact sample is used many times, including right before Carrie screams and season 3 ends). Then she saw herself in the frame, she saw Judy, turning back, she found herself in the entrance to the black lodge, and embodied Judy, momentarily. She had an immense sadness in her eyes at this point. The picture frame allowed Laura to peek into the darkness. Then, she woke up for real, signified by the continuation of Pierre's fire sound finally ending. So, there, Mrs. Chalfont and Pierre were acting as agents of self-discovery and against repression. This was the catalyst for her to see Leland's face, instead of BOB's, for the first time. However, seeing herself in the lodge freaked her out, and she put the picture face down, choosing repression once more. * It will take seeing the ring on Mike in the car, and then realizing she saw this ring on Teresa, and in her dream, to get her to realize BOB is her father. After this realization, she cannot deny it anymore. Putting on the ring, then, facilitates integration of what she has repressed. * The Ring here symbolizes integration, which is why Chet Desmond disappeared after taking the ring (he was actually Cooper) and why Cooper got a bit harder-edged after putting the ring on Mr. C.
**Teresa's Murder**