RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/twitterhelp • … • u/gnosisonic

The "confirm you're a human" biometric account lockout is illegal in Colorado

So yesterday my account was hit with this--probably because I frequently use X on a PC browser with uBlock Origin--and now I'm just stuck at endless "verification failed" screens.

To me, this is one step beyond what is acceptable for a service I'm paying for and which I have used captchas and email verification to access. It's flagrantly totalitarian, and as one reddit user described it here, the "scan your face and scan your hands" demands feel like an intentional ritual of humiliation. It also feels like the exact kind of thing that should be against US law, and today after doing a search I found that in Colorado, where I reside, it is in fact explicitly illegal since July last year.

Here's the bill: [https://leg.colorado.gov/bills/hb24-1130](https://leg.colorado.gov/bills/hb24-1130)

And here's a lawyer's summary: [https://www.paulhastings.com/insights/ph-privacy/colorado-imposes-new-privacy-requirements-on-organizations-collecting-biometric-identifiers-and-data](https://www.paulhastings.com/insights/ph-privacy/colorado-imposes-new-privacy-requirements-on-organizations-collecting-biometric-identifiers-and-data)

Specifically: "An entity that controls or processes biometrics is prohibited from refusing the provision of goods or services, or charging a different rate for goods and services based on a consumer’s refusal to consent to the processing of biometrics."

That's exactly what this situation is: refusing the provision of a service unless you hand over your biometrics. X is breaking the law every time it makes these demands of any user who resides in Colorado.

I'm thinking that since my X account is so important to me (I actually use it to communicate with a community of Japanese friends I have virtually no way of connecting with online except on X), I may actually sue over this. If I do, I think I'll win. So I'm wondering: is anyone else here also in Colorado and affected by this--*or*, is anyone else here in a US state that has a similar law? I'm thinking Colorado is probably not the only state that has a law explicitly prohibiting service denial for the refusal to provide biometrics, but it's difficult to look up the laws of every state. Perhaps we could collaborate on researching this.

For starters, is anyone aware of any other state that bans this explicitly? And, is anyone else here a resident of Colorado affected by this "confirm you're a human" biometric lockout?

I want to do something about this. Laws are real, and they matter, and for me, this company locking me out of a service I pay for and which I have verified through multiple other means crosses a line. These are the exact kind of lines we have to establish firmly in order to not have our world slide into an Orwellian dystopia where these companies and their AIs become more and more disrespectful and oppressive. When people just complain about it, or say "there's nothing you can do," it's *guaranteed to get worse.* So let's do something about it, starting with this state law X is breaking.

How many other US states have also made this behavior illegal?

— 0