Recommendation Request - 16px body font with that Garamond magic

I am looking for something with a little more panache than Times New Roman. I love Garamond in print and on higher resolution monitors, but it can be a little difficult to read on my 1080/1920. It needs to be something, that, if the desire strikes me, I can rubricate by hand and it would look in place. So far my options seem to be Georgia or a slightly weightier Garamond. I'd like to know what other humanist fonts are out there and why I should use them.