RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/ufosmeta • … • u/Silverjerk

Should we hold 3rd party sightings submissions to the same standard as personal sightings threads?

As a reminder, here are the current sighting submission guidelines:

* Must include approximate Location and Date/Time Recorded * Must be related to a detailed and descriptive eyewitness account (can be anonymous) * No trail camera or doorbell camera footage * Must have been seen with eyeballs (No “Look what I found when I looked back at my pictures!”) * No cell phone videos of content on a TV/display. * Interviews, podcasts, documentaries, and articles related to UFOs can still be shared and will not be subject to these posting guidelines.

In general, the goal of r/UFOs is to provide a space for users to share their experiences and engage in open and respectful discussion about UFO sightings. By following these guidelines, topic creators ensure their post is informative, includes useful, actionable data, and contributes to the repository of information within the UFO community.

The submission guidelines for sightings are critically important to properly analyzing the data around a UFO sighting, as they provide a framework for collecting and presenting information in a consistent and organized way. From a scientific perspective, this is essential for conducting objective analysis of the data and drawing meaningful conclusions about the nature of the phenomenon.

In order to conduct this objective analysis, we need details such as the time, location, and duration of the sighting, as well as any relevant contextual information about the weather, terrain, or other factors that may have influenced the observation; witness testimony is also a necessity, and can provide unique insight on characteristics and behaviors that do not present themselves on camera (something Vallee has discussed at length in his work).

By collecting this information in a standardized way, the community can more easily compare and contrast different sightings and identify patterns or trends, working together to rule out common misidentifications and other, prosaic explanations.

Secondly, and perhaps more importantly, the guidelines help to ensure that the information collected is accurate and reliable. By requiring users to provide photo or video evidence of the sighting, and by encouraging users to consider alternative explanations and debunk potential sources of confusion or misidentification, the guidelines help to filter out unreliable or misinterpreted data. This is crucial for ensuring that any analysis conducted on the data is based on reliable and verifiable evidence.

One of the ancillary intentions of these guidelines is to help foster a culture of critical thinking and evidence-based research. As above, this is essential for conducting objective analysis and arriving at those meaningful conclusions.

It is important to hold 3rd party sightings threads to similar standards, in order to raise the quality and reliability of the information being shared. While it may be more challenging for 3rd party topic creators to provide detailed information such as date, time, and location, this information is still crucial to objective analysis.

One way to compromise on the requirements for 3rd parties is to encourage topic creators to provide as much information as possible, and to be transparent about the limitations of the data. For example, they may not know the exact date and time of the sighting, but they could provide a range of dates and a general timeframe (e.g. "sometime in the last week", or "the original content creator posted the sighting on X date and Y time). Similarly, they might not know the exact location, but they could provide a general description of the area, or the possible location of the individual who shared the media (e.g. "over a rural field in the Midwest", or "the original content creator may be located in X city, or Y country").

We should also encourage 3rd parties to provide additional context and analysis to supplement their post. For instance, they might provide additional information about the credibility of the witness, any corroborating evidence, supporting data, or other relevant contextual information that could help shed light on the nature of the sighting. The intention here is to encourage the individual who shared the sighting to "do their diligence" and practice useful tactics for good research and analysis.

Ultimately, the goal of holding 3rd party sightings threads to a more stringent standard is to ensure that the information being shared is as reliable and informative as possible.

Here are some examples of topics which would be considered 3rd party sightings submissions that are currently labeled as "link" posts, consisting of low quality information:

1. A TikTok video of a UFO sighting with little to no information provided by the poster, such as the date, time, and location of the sighting. 2. A tweet from #UFOTwitter that claims to show a UFO sighting but lacks any accompanying context or explanation of what is being shown in the video or image. 3. A news article that reports on a UFO sighting but only provides basic information such as the general location and a brief description of the sighting without any additional details or analysis. 4. A forum post that links to a video of a supposed UFO sighting but lacks any additional information about the witness or their credibility, the date, time, or location of the sighting, or any additional contextual information that could help to shed light on the nature of the sighting.

By holding 3rd parties to the same standard as eyewitnesses, we can ensure that all submissions include the basic level of information required to conduct a rigorous analysis of the sighting. This will help us ensure the credibility and reliability of the information being shared within the community. Which, in turn, will help to further promote a culture of critical thinking and evidence-based analysis, an essential component in advancing our understanding of UFO sightings and other anomalous phenomena.

Here are some examples of these types of "3rd party sightings" topics:

[https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/13cchdb/photographer\_accidentally\_captures\_strange\_lights/](https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/13cchdb/photographer_accidentally_captures_strange_lights/)

[https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/139pzvh/saw\_this\_posted\_on\_another\_ufo\_sub\_its\_pretty/](https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/139pzvh/saw_this_posted_on_another_ufo_sub_its_pretty/)

[https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/13ca95x/an\_acquaintance\_captured\_this\_photo\_while\_hiking/](https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/13ca95x/an_acquaintance_captured_this_photo_while_hiking/)

[https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/13b72sy/demi\_lovato\_claims\_she\_saw\_a\_ufo\_last\_night/](https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/13b72sy/demi_lovato_claims_she_saw_a_ufo_last_night/)

These are just a small number of the 3rd party sightings we see daily on r/UFOs. My suggestion is that we use this thread to formulate a list of "guidelines" with a basic set of requirements. These might include linking to the original topic creator or providing a direct link to the content on the relevant social media platform; and/or increasing the minimum character count requirement for these posts.

The intention is not to "curate" or censor content, but, again, to improve the quality of information. For some, r/UFOs is still viewed as a media repository, and sensationalist topics still heavily dominate engagement and garner the most discussion. While I admit that I'm no expert, I can still point to several threads at the top of our sub that even I, as an advocate for the phenomenon and longtime believer, question the validity of; they remain popular because they are seen as entertainment; not valid data. By continuing to encourage users to post this type of content and holding them to a lower bar, we're fostering an environment where entertaining media has more value than useful, actionable data.

— 0