RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/ukraine • … • u/kmoonster

It looks like the first lawsuit touching on Trump's threat to revoke 'protected' status for Ukrainians in the US was been filed. More lawsuits are likely to follow. Some initial thoughts & links inside. US Citizens - a simple suggestion you can act on.

I can't promise the best outcome, but so far precedent is on the side of the plaintiffs (complainants). In his first term there were several successful lawsuits that continued protections for people fleeing crises in their homelands, and some dragged on so long that Trump's term ended before the suit(s) ended.

It is never possible to know the outcome in advance, but there are groups and individuals carrying these lawsuits forward with every intention of smacking down his threats.

This one specifically includes at least some Ukrainians who ended up in the US as a result of the full-scale invasion (note: I'm not sure if it explicitly covers all, but if this suit wins then it becomes easier to sue for expanding the continued protections to all categories of applicants).

Here: [Svitlana-Doe-v.-Noem-Hum-Parole-Complaint-2.28.25.pdf](https://justiceactioncenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Svitlana-Doe-v.-Noem-Hum-Parole-Complaint-2.28.25.pdf)

Venezuelans were the first group he targeted, going after their status after being in office only a few days. There are at least two or three active lawsuits for other humanitarian parole, asylees, or other emergency visa types from Venezuela.

This lawsuit is a bit wider and includes quite a few more categories/groups of applicants.

Some notes on the document in general:

* "Doe" is not an actual name. "Doe" is a surname replacement for when the person/people are being shielded from public identification, it's a way to anonymize someone in a sensitive case. * The people with full names listed are sponsors, advocates, or lawyers; not victims * Haitian Bridge Alliance is an organization adding their experience and "standing" to expand the case to include all affected people and not just the specific individuals listed (the listed are primary in the case, sort of like "examples", everyone else is included but not listed) * Kristi Noem was formerly a governor, now serves as the head of Department of Homeland Security; this is the department of which Border Patrol and Immigration & Customs Enforcement are a part. The lawsuit also cites US Citizenship and Immigration Services (yet another agency) as well as Trump. * Tom Homan (head of Immigration enforcement) is not named, but he is only the "muscle". The lawsuit is naming the decision makers and not the people who organize the ground-work * 1 -11 list specific complaints * 12 lists a desired remedy or outcome * 13-14 explain why the particular court / jurisdiction was chosen * 15-31 explain why each person or group has reason to participate in this case * 32-152 are history and how the social & political situations evolved over the course of time to create the conditions which are now being complained about * Most of the remainder explains the harms experienced so far and/or harms which are reasonably expected as a result of the change of policy, * as well as allegations that the decisions/actions of the defendants (the government agencies in this case) are responsible for the harms, and that * those harms can be halted or reversed if the court intercedes to return the situation to its prior condition.

\- - -

Three additional lawsuits (below) are related, but they do not directly relate to Ukrainians in the US on temporary or emergency status. These are active lawsuits, but if resolved before the more explicitly Ukrainian suits then these may serve as precedent, or "you did it for them, therefore you can do it for us". A positive outcome for the complainants in any or all of these would bode well for a positive outcome in the case with the Ukrainians I linked above.

[CASA, Inc. v. Noem, 8:25-cv-00525 – CourtListener.com](https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69656739/casa-inc-v-noem/)

[New York Immigration Coalition v. Donald J. Trump, 1:25-cv-01309 – CourtListener.com](https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69638232/unknown-case-title/)

[National TPS Alliance v. Noem, 3:25-cv-01766 – CourtListener.com](https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69655305/national-tps-alliance-v-noem/)

\- - -

Like I said, there are no promises here but this information may prove useful to you or be a resource to share if someone asks whether you know anything. The idiom in English is "it's early days" but hopefully this will help you get started on understanding what some of your options might be and what future headlines you might be seeing.

\- - -

**Note: if you are an American citizen, consider contacting your state's Attorney General to file a complaint and ask the state to initiate or join a suit** (they usually work under the governor's office handling legal issues the state is involved in). Some state AGs and/or governors are quite anti-immigrant and perhaps should be avoided (Florida comes to mind), but many states are likely to be amenable to defending their residents from the sort of chaos that will result from mass revocations of status, and/or the humanitarian crisis that could result if Trump succeeds. California and New York appear to be on other, similar suits, and many states such as Colorado, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Washington, etc. are likely to be amenable, especially since this type of action is now becoming a pattern of the White House and not a one-off event.

If your state's office is professional and/or amenable to these concerns, consider calling them or filling out their webform asking whether the state can form or join a lawsuit against DHS. It is important to note that state AGs prefer potential cases that show a 'pattern or practice' rather than a one-off offense by the group or person you are complaining about. **This is at least the second? third? more? such effort or announcement since Trump took office**, the count depending on what is considered an offense (if a statement of intent counts then there are far more parts of the pattern).

It is ok, and even good, to have multiple lawsuits filed in different ways and with differing specifics; sometimes similar cases may be merged during the appeals process, sometimes not. But for starting out, having multiple cases from multiple jurisdictions is a good thing for matters of this scale.

— 0