RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/ukraine • … • u/VoR_Mom

Russian Archaeologist Faces Charges for Unauthorized Excavations in Occupied Crimea - Archaeologs

Archeologists usually are mind-bendingly unpolitical when it comes to their work. They'll work together with their worst enemy. If the science is sound. Russian archeology has a long tradition of being political. From the earliest years of the Soviet Union it was only allowed when it served the political narrative. See Sarmatians, for example. they show clear Scythian origins and Celtic influences in the area of Crimea. But anything western wasn't allowed in Russia, so the only permitted narrative was one of many successive immigration waves of Iranic people as far as Afghanistan (same as the narrative for the Scythians, basically). But since Sarmatian and Scythian royal graves are found in Moldova and western Ukraine, it's a convenient ideological excuse to say they have "always been part of the same people". That only works, of course, if Sarmatians are not, in part, Celtic or even worse, Germanic.

Sadly, since this narrative was force-taught for over a hundred years, and everyone who didagreed was banned from working or deported, it's deeply entrenched in Ukrainian archeology as well and isn't being challenged. Though dissenting voices have been around for decades, saying that the finds don't match the story.

see for example: https://www.academia.edu/resource/work/12146520

The above example is about antiquity, but it doesn't matter if it's Cucuteni-Trypillia or the Roman Empire or Greeks. Don't trust Russian archeology.

— 0