RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/ukraine • … • u/Boshva

Unpopular Opinion: NATO/EU immediately announcing no intervention was one of the biggest political blunders of the 21st century

Hey guys,

as pretty much the rest of the bigger subs I visit on Reddit forbids to either talk about it, maybe you will be interested about this opinion.

Wall of text:

My arguments:

1. NATO saying immediately that there will be no intervention opened Putin the door to do whatever he wants as there is no Red Line.

2. Sanctions won‘t stop the war and won‘t stop Russia from escalating further.

3. Interventions does neither mean WW3 nor does it mean nuclear holocaust.

First of all, why this post? I am pretty annoyed about the sentiment in the west (i am from Germany) that neither EU nor NATO should make any move. Honestly, people are immediately screaming about WW3 and nuclear war before you finish your sentence. And it doesnt even make sense to me.

1. About the first point. By telling Putin and Russia that there will be no military intervention by any state, you pretty much handed the russian military a blanco check to do whatever and use whatever they want.

Putin already sees the West as some kind of decadent cesspool that won‘t do anything that would hurt their own economy. Well, at least we managed to impose some sanctions and send some weapons, rather late than soon. But this wont stop Russia in any way. And what is there for Russia to „fear“. Yes their soldiers will die a bloody death at the Ukrainian hands, who defend their motherland with such heroism. But russian leadership does not care about money and their people currently.

I really hope that US intelligence sees some way out for Ukraine without intervention. Because that would at least make sense to me, why there is no support by at least some non nuclear powers. Instead of it being pure fear or egoism.

2. Which brings me to my second point. The imposed sanctions wont stop Russia. Putin already turned the total russian state around, which is comparable to Hitlers „Gleichschaltung“. Gleichschaltung meant the forced incorporation of the cultural, societal, economical and political sphere into one ideology. And i hate nazi comparisons as they are usually done by edgy kids. I am cautious with the word Nazi and fascism as it is overused online and Russia is not quiet there yet by definition. But they are definitely doing a speed run. But in this case we see it with the media, schools and military.

Still Putins Russia is getting cracks. Loads of dead soldiers not returning home, massive police presence, economy is on life support. He surrounded him with yes-men and puppets. There will be no internal uprising. At least not now. It took germany 4 years of the most horrible war to surrender in the first WW1.

So how do you paper over such cracks? With more war! Nothing unites a country more than an external threat. (Even if it is not real) When the planes hit on 9/11, Bushs approval rating jumped from 50 to 86%! He was the same idiot before 9/11 and he stayed the same idiot after. But during crisis you rally behind your leader and your country. We see that partially with the Russian polls. No questions asked. And as i dont see Putin stepping down, he needs the war to continue, even after Ukraine.

3. Lets talk about the last topic. I am against a no fly zone. This would imply that, whoever is enforcing it, also has to bomb Russian territory to destroy air defense. But still there is other options. (Humanitarian corridors, anti air craft etc.) I am for military intervention. It would end the war sooner and save lives. First of all, it does not mean WW3. As i dont see anyone outside of Europe entering this war. I do not even see whole of Europe entering this war. But rather a coalition of the willing.

Regarding the nuclear weapons: Whatever the EU or NATO does, Putin may be paranoid, but he is not suicidal. He will not start a nuclear war as long as Russian territory is not under immediate attack. It is like saying that the US is starting nukes the first minute a Russian soldiers steps into Alaska. This will be the absolute last resort for anyone. Nuclear warheads are defensive weapons. They are there to scare the enemy.

But it works BOTH WAYS. There is a LONG LONG way of escalation between intervention and nuclear war. Look at the cuban missile crisis or look up Stanislaw Jewgrafowitsch Petrow. When it comes to the absolut red line, usually both parties find a solution or the people in the command chain dismiss to blow up half of the planet for minor reasons.

In my opinion the NATO/EU is not intervening either because they have some very good intel which NOONE has or which is more likely, there is just no public or political support in the western hemisphere for an intervention currently.

Yes you read that right, people are supportive of Ukraine, but lots of them would probably not support their own soldiers fighting there (excluding baltics and Poland). The german sentiment is pretty clear here. I do not know the turning point for this to change. Zelensky was right, how many Ukrainian body parts have to fly around until something happens?

And it is heartbreaking to me. After the Afghanistan desaster, there is finally one country turning to the west, to democracy and fighting for their independence. And the west does not do their absolut best to support this? What message are we sending to Moldova, Belorussians, Georgians, Taiwanese and all the other fighting for the same cause? The message is that it isnt worth to fight for the freedom of your country, as the western nations are not willing to make their hands dirty.

I hope this turns out as good as possible for the Ukrainian people.

Слава Україні

TLDR: Even with Intervention it would still be local war, without global powers fighting directly. Intervention would end this far sooner and end the misery in Ukraine. The war wont stop just because of sanctions.

— 0