I am reading Umineko (almost) completely blind. Just finished chapter 5. Here are my thoughts and theories. [tl;dr at the end]
Hello there!
So first of all let me say this: **no spoilers will be tolerated,** and **I will not be checking or answering any replies until I finish the VN** (if there are any) in order to avoid such spoilers.
# I - Context
I finished reading Higurashi back in March, after a year and a half of breaks, going back and forth into reading it. I absolutely loved the plot twists as well as the endind. And back then, I couldn't wait to play Umineko after hearing so much good stuff about it from two of my oomfs (especially movses, if you read this, tysm), and so far, it's been a bliss reading it: the characters, the story, the music GOD the music... and the murder mystery keeps me glued on my seat every time something weird happens.
I particularly loved chapter 1 for how little we are exposed to magic during it: I think that was done by Ryukishi on purpose to make us slowly descend into madness, into turning to occult ways of thinking, but I'll come back to that. Chapters 2 3 and 4 were awesome as well even though I was a bit thrown off by all the new "magic" characters suddenly making their first appearance during the murders, I initially thought it completely ruined the mystery, but now that I have my theories, I do not believe so anymore.
Now onto the real matter: WHAT THE HELL DID HAPPEN IN THIS MANSION.
Well. I have a few theories about that, but before trying to find a Mr. or Ms. Whodunnit, first I think it's necessary to discuss what I think magic *actually* is.
# II - Magic
During the question arc chapters and especially during chapter 1, Battler firmly believes that magic does not exist and insists that someone, a real person, is behind the murders, but never manages to prove it and eventually dies alongside the other 4.
What I noticed is that Beatrice (the mascot of this VN if I dare say so) *never* appears in this chapter. I think there is a reason for it and I actually mentioned it earlier: **we cannot see her because Battler is convinced that she does not exist.** At this point Battler is the main protagonist of this story, so we only see the story though his own eyes - and considering it all happens in the first chapter, we as the reader are not properly intoxicated with all this magic narrative yet. The thing is, the fact that not a single clue points us to any culprit, we eventually end up giving up finding any logic in it, and slowly start accepting that this is just a story about silly witches. (source: myself).
Which in turns explains another question: why can we all of a sudden see the witch and her servants comitting the murders in chapters 2-3-4? Because at that point we as **the reader have already accepted magic as the explanation** deep down, and because Battler is not present during these scenes. And precisely since Battler did not see that unfold under his own eyes, we can't take these events at face value.
Chapters 3 & 4 go deeper into Eva, Maria, Rosa and Ange's backstories and what we can clearly see is that all these characters had it rough. Eva was barred from any chances at pursuing a career by her own father and siblings just for being a woman, Maria is neglected by her own mother (and her dad abandonned both of them), but the worse part is Ange who literally lost her whole family in a horrible murder case with the perpetrators still roaming free 12 years later, with her getting bullied in class and her aunt trying to abduct her. And in chapter 5 (which I have now finished at the time of continuing this article/post), Natsuhi is framed as the "culprit" with her past cited as the motive, not being able to get pregnant and also being rejected by Kinzo and even her own husband.
We notice that all these characters have been able to use magic to some extent, three of them even becoming witches. It used to be a theory in ch4 but now in ch5 I think it's pretty much confirmed the witches they see are just illusions, or rather their own idealistic idea of the Ushiromiya family portrayed through the Witch, the Alchemist of the Ushiromiya Family. This explains why Beatrice is serving Eva in ch3, or Natsuhi in ch5.
So there remains the question: **what is magic?**
I believe it depends on how you see it. If you see magic as some supernatural power a la Harry Potter, I think there's no such thing in the Umineko universe (if you can call it that way). I prefer to liken it as the **manifestation of someone's deepest sentiments, uncertainties and determination** — actually, the witches are the very representations of our heroes' wishes, mourning and sadness.
Kinzo lost his lover and tried to revive her through the occult. Eva wanted to be recognized as a woman and not as a mere female in a sexist bourgeois family and thus sought to become a superior being. Maria, having most likely a behaviour disorder like autism (I am autistic myself and can relate to her a LOT (the screams, the special interest and hyperfixation for it)), it feels natural that she'd be into those stories as a coping mechanism, and to be in her own world.
Now back to the most practical sense of magic: I don't remember when it was said but I do remember one of the characters saying "Just because you can't explain something with logic, doesn't mean it's magic". People in the Middle Ages, especially women, often used to be put on trial for witchcraft. Scientists during that time were also facing death on the stake for exposing religion and bringing scientific explanations to explain our world. After all, when we can't explain how something happens, it's easier to assume it's just magic, rather than bringing logic and scientific research on the table right?
But now... if magic doesn't really exist, what happened?
*...who did it?*
# III - The culprit?
If this is not a tale about real witches slicing poor innocent people's throats for naught — if the murders of Rokkenjima aren't the fruit of magic, then those are most likely the fruit of one or several human culprit(s). And if the murders are rooted in logic and the culprit is human, there must be clues hidden throughout the story.
Have I found these clues? ...No. ^((yeah sorry that's embarassing. I'm... not that great at noticing little details.)) However this doesn't mean I have ZERO theories on whatever the fridge is happening on that island.
And actually, I'll start by stating one thing which I had doubts about before ch5 but now I'm even more convinced about it: **I'm not sure if red truths can be 100% be trusted.** I know it's been stated that red truths are absolutely undeniable and accurate, but Ch5 has demonstrated that several truths contradicting themselves can coexist, which would be impossible without causing paradoxes and violating core physical principles in the real world. Does that mean red truths are fake though? I'm not sure either, so just in case, I'll consider them as real for now.
Let's assume the island is closed off during the typhoon, which would in theory make it impossible for anyone else beside the 18 characters to be our mastermind. However, if additional person there is, they could always come before the typhoon arrives without anyone noticing. Now obviously, in this chapter, almost all murders are "closed room" murders, which are notoriously difficult to solve. If we consider Knox's rule to be true, then there are in theory no hidden passages. That being said, this poses the question of what a hidden passage is: doesn't the hidden library count as one? Same with the room with all the gold in it?
Another disturbing thing is how the survivors vary every time in each chapter. Among the last ch1 survivors being Battler, Natsuhi, Jessica, George and Maria, only one has never been murdered in the other chapters yet: Battler. And actually, unless I'm making a mistake, of all the 18 people, only Battler wasn't targeted. Which means it can go two ways: either this is plot armor, or Battler is the culprit. But wait.... what did Virgilia say in red earlier? That's right: "Ushiromiya Battler isn't the culprit. This can be said of all games". So it's not Battler! Right? Well... there's still the possibility that the Battler we know isn't actually Battler. After all, Beato did say in red that he's not Asumu's son. After finishing Ch5's tea party (which I almost missed by the way, since I usually don't read those), there's a definite possibility that our boy might not be who we think he is. *There's also that part about the sin he commited 6 years ago, we still don't know what that is*
But! There's also the motive to be taken into account! I believe most of the hints to that are hidden in Ch4, when Ange comes back to Rokkenjima 12 years later. The fact that those letters with the keys to the family's safe were sent to the surviving members of the family and servants is truly weird. I ASSUME the motive has to do with **money**, succession and inheritence. IF Battler did carry out those murders, that would mean that 1) he is theorically still alive, which I find contradicting (why would he be so clueless then??) 2) he'd have some reason to take the inheritance to himself 3) What about Ange? Considering how he seemed to like her, it would be very weird to play dead let her all alone
So all in all, **I find it hard for Battler to be the killer/mastermind**. But if not him, then I have no idea who lmao.
That being said, I believe two things: first, after exposing my thoughts about what magic is and who witches are, **I strongly believe that Beatrice is not real, and the real culprit is using her as a cover up.** If you can use witches to free your mind and become who you want to be, surely you can use one to hide your true identity. Second, I believe the human culprit theory isn't the only theory we should explore.
# IV - This world...
In my opinion, and that's where I'm taking the most risks, there are other theories to consider to explain the events of Rokkenjima as well as the world of Umineko, and I'll explain them briefly down below. That being said, I wrote those one month ago after finishing ch4 so take these with indulgence.
**I have three main theories to explain the events of Rokkenjima:** 1) The events are a direct target against the Ushiromiyas's wealth 2) None of the murders happened 3) It's all fake / it's a simulation
For the first one, I already went a little on it but basically: **it's obvious that money has to do something with the cases.** Money easily sits in the top 3 of the biggest motives for murder, and thus it's quite easy to imagine someone would want to keep all the inheritance for themselves. As I already said though, I have almost no idea who it would be, only that they're using Beato as a pseudonym/coverup.
For the second one, I initially thought that all the events could just be a series of hallucinations (similar to some of the events in Higurashi), maybe with drugs involved, but after completing Ch5, I'm not so sure about that anymore. One of Knox's commandments does claim that no external elements can be brought to explain the crimes. That being said, if we forget about that, **a theory where none of the murders happened could explain why the victims are different every time.** One thing often mentionned by witches is that *"anti-magic toxin"* thing. What is it? Is it just a made up concept constructed to illustrate logic, or is there actually a toxin or chemical agent that prevents people on Rokkenjima from hallucinating?
My third and last theory is by far the most far fetched one so far but it wouldn't surprise me if it turned out real: **what if everything we saw up until now was just... fictional? Simulated?** I KNOW IT'S STUPID BUT HEAR ME OUT. Something I noticed is that the way some characters talk is... surprising, to say the least. Take the Chiester Sisters: they often talk using error codes anytime their magic does not work. Take Dlanor: I may be delusional but the way she talks sounds way too much like a computer to me 🤔 Simulation tropes aren't new in visual novels: we can site >!DDLC!< or >!Danganronpa 2 and v3!<among probably others. If Umineko takes place inside some sort of computer, then everything suddely becomes easier to explain: the game board? The murders? An actual game. Witches? Some sort of viruses. Red truths? Just mere lines of code used to overwrite previous truths. The game master? The administrator. And by that logic, Dlanor as well as the other inquisitors could be antiviruses. One last argument I'll present is the following: I once accidentally saw fanart of Beatrice portrayed as a glitch, however I was told that I wasn't a spoiler, so I suspect it could just be metaphoric.
# CONCLUSION
There's so much stuff going on in Umineko, it's genuinely crazy how Ryukishi stepped up after Higurashi. I'm not regretting my 120+ hours of reading so far, and whatever the truth turns out to be, I hope it will blow me away, just like my friend Movses told me it would.
**tl;dr: I believe magic does not exist and is just a representation of the characters' desires, the culprit if there is one is probably an inpersonator who uses the witch Beatrice as a cover up in order to steal the Ushiromiya assets, and there's a chance the whole story is just a hallucination or worse, a mere simulation.**
**Ending prediction: Battler becomes a witch, takes control of the game board, invokes Ange as a piece, she catches the culprit, and Battler, with his new powers, denies magic forever**
Watch me getting it COMPLETELY WRONG and making a fool of myself once the truth is revealed to me in a few dozens of hours of reading, but it'll be worth it. Dear Umineko enjoyers and fans, I hope you had a good laugh reading this, the theories of a delusional guy who has absolutely no clue of what he is reading.
On that note, I wish all of you a great rest of your day. <3