RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/unOrdinary • … • u/Morbu

Why John is no longer the "hero" of the story

I've been seeing a lot of people completely siding with John beating the shit of Remi and co., and it kind of saddens me because I don't think this is what the author was trying to convey in the slightest. So, I'm going to share my reasoning why John isn't someone that we, the readers, should be supporting at this point in the story.

First of all, **his goal:** **To destroy the hierarchy.**

Simple.

**His reasoning?** **Low-tiers are oppressed by high-tiers and treated inhumanely.**

Ok, fair enough.

**His methodology? To beat the shit out of every Royal in order to show that their power isn't absolute.**

Ok, let's unpack that one.

John's whole stated purpose to bringing down the hierarchy is to establish order between the lower-tiers and the high-tiers. Some actual examples in history of this kind of thing occurring would be the French Revolution and the Bolshevik/Russian Revolution. However, unlike in those cases, John isn't a populist. Remember when Sera was talking to the low-tiers, and they said that they got some weird vibes from John? Yeah, that's because John never actually associated himself with the low-tiers, yet he's acting like he's fighting for them. If he TRULY believed that low-tiers and high-tiers should be treated equally, he would've banded the low-tiers together to fight against the high-tiers. However, instead, he's doing it all by himself. Why? Because Arlo personally messed with John, and high-tiers messed with Sera -- his best friend.

I mean, think about it, if John was TRULY being empathetic to low-tiers and their suffering, he would've done something AGES ago. That's the whole reason his dad wrote Unordinary if anyone even remembers that. Yet, John went on his merry way and tried to keep his head low. It's only when the "system" affected him personally that he got involved.

Furthermore, let's imagine what's going to happen when, or if, John actually succeeds. The high-tiers are going to be stripped of status, and they're going to be on "equal grounds" with the low-tiers. And, if the high-tiers act out and try to beat up the low-tiers? Well, John is likely going to beat the shit out of them to put them back into place because he's the strongest. And what's going to happen when John leaves? Well, the old hierarchy will come back. In other words, it's going to be the exact repeat of what Remi's brother tried to do except that while John is in power, he will be the only "Royal" with any say (i.e. a dictator).

So, taking into consideration all the points I made above, John's actual goal is this:

**To destroy the hierarchy and replace it with a new one where he's the only one at the top.**

His actual reasoning:

**Because his life was personally messed with, and he wants revenge.**

His methodology:

**To beat the shit out of every Royal to show that their power isn't absolute but HIS is.**

Let's get real with ourselves. In just about ANY other story, John would be an antagonist. His crusade is 100% self-serving, and it's not to the benefit of anyone but himself. He criticizes the system for prioritizing power above all else, but by oppressing everyone with his power, he's actually serving the system more than anyone.

— 0