RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/unRAID • … • u/daggah

Best way to go about replacing all drives?

I currently have 6x6 TB WD Reds in my server. The drives are almost 8 years old. My \[Drive 1\] in my array just started throwing errors and showing reallocated sectors (525 at this moment) so it's definitely on the way out. Given the age of the rest of my drives, I am taking this as a sign that they're reaching EOL and going to be replacing them with 4x14 TB WD Ultrastar drives from ServerPartDeals.

Given that one of the drives is already failing, I'm a little concerned about straining the other drives when I'm replacing everything. I'm figuring the absolute safest way to do this is to pull the drives, install the new ones, pre-clear and build a new array, and the transfer data from the old drives one by one. That's obviously a long process involving a lot of downtime. I could also pull and swap out drives one at a time starting with parity, which would also be a longer process, but with less downtime. I just worry about the strain that would put on the rest of my old 6 TB drives in the process; it seems like that could trigger more drive failures.

For the most part, most of the data on my server is not irreplaceable and I have backups of critical data that can't be replaced, but man, reacquiring the rest of the content would be a HUGE pain in the ass.

— 0