RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/unRAID • … • u/admalledd

Sanity check me before I replace my disks

I currently have a collection of 8TB drives, 7 drives total: two parity and five data. [See here](https://www.admalledd.com/dl/img/screenshots/Screenshot_20251025_211148.png) for ref.

Due to Disk1 failing, I am deciding to upgrade my array to 26TB drives. I have four of these drives on hand.

Of course, my concern is the "how to safely upgrade/move to the four 26TB drives?" and sanity checking my procedure.

Desired *end state* is two parity, two data, with ~50TB usable between the four. Too many near scares with dead drives over my life, I like my double parity.

So, most of the guides and notes talk about "Parity Swap" etc if the drive is *larger*. However, I have worries since D1 isn't healthy.

My current thought is a longer process of:

Plan "A", if I roughly follow docs/forums/etc:

1. Replace *just* Disk1 with a new 26TB drive (will this even work?) 2. Let array rebuild and become happy 3. Replace one of the parity drives (just in case a drive dies while everything goes on) 4. Let array rebuild and become happy 5. Replace other parity drive 6. Let array rebuild and become happy 7. Add last 26TB drive to array (total drives now *8*: Disks 2-5 remain 8TBs) 8. Use rsync/unballance/etc to move all existing data to the two 26TB drives 9. Remove 8TB drives 10. "New Config" the array with the four 26TB drives, two in parity, two as data 11. ??? profit?

* Pros of this plan: faster in theory, much less manual data shuffling around

* Cons of this plan: more risks, especially significantly more rebuilds on already "old" drives with which one failed. Unknown if/how UnRaid will detect/handle that multiple "replacement" drives are 26TB instead of desired 8TBs, will the formatting be for 8tb or the full 26? "New Config" won't resize the partitions/formatting will it?

Plan "B" I've also been thinking of:

1. Use USB adapter, add two 26TB drives as external devices, copy bulk array data manually to the two drives (current array has ~31TB used, so it'll all fit) 2. Last-minute `rsync` all `appdata`, docker.img, VM images, etc stuff to a spare 1TB SSD 3. pull *all* the 8TBs out 4. "New Config" a new array using 1x Parity and 1x Data 5. Empty one of the external drives to the new array 6. add now-empty drive to array 7. Empty other external drive to the array 8. add now-empty drive as second party

* Pros: Leaves all my old drives as-is "just in case" * Cons: sloooowwwww USB rsync to off-load ~30TB, keeping in track/mind what to "final rsync" of bulk-data. Server this is on only has one USB2.0 port usable. Cannot add more, no spare PCIe/etc. Maybe connect drive over network from another computer? But then CPU/network overheads...

I am almost more leaning to plan "B", just for the safety it gives by leaving the existing drives mostly alone.

Anyone have alternate plans/thoughts? Ways to do this "better"? Anything horribly obvious I am missing?

— 0