Best way to replace a failing drive in a system that is not parity protected?
I purchased a new drive about a week ago, it is making a clicking noise while reading or writing. I believe this is a sign of drive failure? Either way I'm going to just return it while I still can.
I'm unsure on the safest way to remove the data from it though. I currently only have room for 3 drives in my case and all 3 slots are filled.
I have two 4 tb drives, and one 10 tb drive (failing)
The way I see it, I have three options:
Option 1: Use unbalancer to move everything off the failing drive and onto the other drives. Once that is complete, replace the failing drive and then use unbalancer again to move data to the new drive.
This option leads to both 4 tb drives having only 500gb of space on them and leads to extra reading and writing on them.
Option 2: I have an external USB enclosure. I was thinking I could connect that and add the new drive that way, move the contents of the failing drive to the new drive, and then once that's done replace the failing drive with the new one.
My only concern is that it will get tricky with the array settings, would the new drive be seen as a different drive when connected via USB vs sata?
Option 3: Remove one of the 4 tb drives keeping its data intact, and replace it with an empty new drive. Add the new drive to the array and us unbalancer to move the contents of failing drive to new drive. When that is complete, remove failing drive and reinstert the removed 4tb drive.
I know a parity drive would make this significantly easier, it's just not in the budget right now. Please advise on the best way to handle this or let me know if there's a better option than mine.
Thanks for any help!