The puzzles in King's Quest V are not that bad.
This is a controversial opinion for sure, but I stand by it. People unfairly point to King's Quest V as having unpredictable dead ends, but they're nothing unique to the particular game. The two biggest so-called offenders are eating the pie and not saving the mouse from the cat, so let me address those individually.
Yes, you get the pie early in the game. And yes, you can eat it as soon as you get it, and not lose the game until hours later when you're supposed to throw it at the yeti. But WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT?! If you've ever played any other adventure game, you know that every item is going to be used in some way. If you eat the pie and nothing happens, this should be a big clue that you should restore an earlier save and keep the pie for whenever it's needed.
This isn't the first time something like this is possible in the series, either. In the first two King's Quest games, you can drop any item and it's gone forever. There is never a time that you will need to do this. The drop functionality is literally only programmed in the game as a way to make you lose. By the 5th entry, people should know better than to be careless with items.
The mouse is a similar story, with the difference being that it's a timed event. If you don't save the mouse from the cat before they're off the screen, you can't beat the game. That's true. But again, why would you not do that? You enter a sceeen and see a cat chasing a mouse. You haven't seen this before, and you can't leave and come back to retrigger the event. It should be pretty clear that you need to reload your game until you figure out what to do.
Obviously, the game is far from perfect. Cedric is the worst animal companion in any game ever, and it's annoying in retrospect that the first half of the game is a fetch quest to get a tambourine to scare away a snake. But the hatred for the puzzles is entirely overblown and unjustified, and I won't stand for it.