RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/ussoccer • … • u/pitchequipment

My USMNT 26-man roster probability rankings with 3 months to go — who am I wrong about?

Been tracking \~48 USMNT-eligible players all season. Here's where I have everyone right now:

Locks (85%+):

Pulisic (99%), Balogun (95%), McKennie (95%), Antonee Robinson (95%), Freese (92%), Adams (90%), Weah (90%), Dest (88%), Richards (88%), Ream (88%)

Strong (65-84%):

Tillman (80%), Miles Robinson (75%), Pepi (75%), Roldan (72%), Brenden Aaronson (70%), Tessmann (68%), Reyna (65%), Haji Wright (65%)

Coin flip (50-64%):

McKenzie (60%), Celentano (60%), Freeman (60%), Trusty (60%), Diego Luna (60%), Horvath (55%), Schulte (50%), Arfsten (50%), Noahkai Banks (50%), Agyemang (50%)

On the outside (25-49%):

Sargent (40%), Scally (40%), Berhalter (40%), Musah (35%), Cardoso (35%), De la Torre (35%), Aidan Morris (35%), Paredes (35%), Steffen (30%), Busio (30%), Vazquez (30%), Zimmerman (30%), Turner (25%), Jordan Morris (25%), Shaq Moore (25%), Paxten Aaronson (20%)

My spiciest takes:

1. Tim Ream at 88% — 38 years old in MLS. But Pochettino won't stop calling him in. At some point you just accept the man is making the roster.

2. Matt Turner at 25% — Went from Arsenal to the Revs. Freese has GK1 locked down and the GK2/GK3 race is Celentano, Horvath, and Schulte. But here's the counter-argument: Turner has big-game experience that none of those guys do. Pochettino might value that the same way he values Ream — the "been there" factor. Don't be shocked if Turner sneaks back in.

3. Musah at 35% — Two years ago he looked like a future star. But he's been underperforming at club level and barely getting minutes at Atalanta. Potential doesn't fill a roster spot — form does.

4. Noahkai Banks at 50% and rising — 19 years old, starting in the Bundesliga for Augsburg. ESPN just profiled him as a legit World Cup dark horse. Bundesliga-average at CB sounds boring until you remember he's a teenager. If he keeps this up through spring, he could leapfrog Zimmerman and Trusty.

5. GK3 is genuinely a coin flip — Schulte, Celentano, and Horvath are all within 10 points. This might be the last roster spot decided.

The question I keep coming back to: Does Pochettino prioritize current form or raw talent? Because the answer changes at least 5 spots on this list.

Who am I overrating? Underrating? Who's missing?

— 0