Poch's talent evaluation
I know everyone is in love with Poch right now but allow me to add on to the glaze for a minute. Now that we have three group games in the book and have seen both the starters and the backups, I think everyone needs to give credit where credit is due: Poch has absolutely nailed his evaluation of the players on this team.
This can be a pitfall for managers and has been for USMNT in the past - managers stubbornly holding onto their favorites where more talented players ride the bench. Hell it's even happening at this world cup on other teams with plenty of criticism for some high profile managers over their lineup selections. But look at the game last night, and then think back to some of the controversies or discussions at different positions over this cycle, and I think we just have to appreciate the fact that it looks like he has gotten basically every decision right.
**Balogun vs. Pepi**: I'll be honest, I never really understood the people who thought Pepi was better, but that absolutely was a take I saw here. Looks laughable in hindsight.
**Richards, Freeman, Ream**: Of these three, only Richards was basically unquestioned assuming his health. For Freeman, some questioned why he was selected for the team at all, plenty questioned if he should start. Has paid off every bit. Ream was being questioned even pre-Australia game because people thought he would turn to dust against fast forwards. And then you see the center back play last night and you know that he is absolutely the best option. There are legitimately coaches who wouldn't have called Ream up at all simply due to his age.
**Weah vs. Dest**: Another one that looks silly in hindsight, but Dest has been absolutely cooking and looks like a revitalized player under Poch. Using Freeman to free Dest up to maraud forward and attack has been brilliant. If Weah was the pick and he performed like he did last night, he would have killed so many attacks.
**Freese vs. Turner**: Another controversy where it looks like Poch has made the correct call. Turner was woeful last night and Freese, while unspectacular IMO, has been better in the USMNT shirt. This was a non-obvious decision, Turner had been the locked in starter for years but Poch was open to changing it and good thing he did.
**Tillman vs. infinite midfielders (Berhalter, Reyna, Aaronson, Zendejas, Musah, Luna) etc.** Worth noting that when Poch came into the team everyone assumed our midfield at this World Cup was MMA - McKennie Musah Adams. Again Poch doesn't assume, but actually evaluates the position. Musah is dropped entirely (does anyone really miss him?) and Poch favors Tillman for the starting role, who definitely has performed a cut above the other options. Even when looking at the midfield group from a substitute perspective, Poch has definitely favored some substitutes over others, and again it looks like he is getting it right. Berhalter has been the first name off the bench and showed why last night - another player that has faced plenty of criticism throughout the cycle. Some people didn't want to bring Reyna at all and he scores a wonder goal in the first game.
You could mayyybe criticize some minor decisions at the end of the roster - maybe there's an argument for Luna over someone like Zendejas, maybe there's an argument to not take Miles Robinson and include an additional midfielder like Tanner Tessman or something, maybe Haji Wright should get a bit more playing time, but again these are so minor and it looks like the most important thing - finding a starting lineup and consistent substitutes that work well - Poch has absolutely nailed.