RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/velocitybanking • … • u/C1ue1ess_Turt1e

Using Savings Instead of LOC

I want to start by saying I am not anti velocity banking and currently use it and it clearly works. I do wonder if maybe there is a better way.

So I currently have thought about if I put my entire paycheck into a high yield savings account (hysa) and then at the end of the month take out enough money from it to pay everything (having positive cash flow to not deplete the hysa) then why shouldn’t I do that instead of putting my money into a line of credit.

Example: Say you have $500 cash flow every month.

So using the LOC with 9% interest (my current situation) and taking out $5,000, it will take 10 months to pay it back, but also there is interest accruing. Weekly paychecks of $625 ($2500/month) go into the LOC and $2,000 comes out at the end of the month. For easy math let’s put in $2,500 at the start of the month to have less interest and then take out the $2,000 at the end.

End month 1: $4,500 + $33.75 (int) = $4,533.75 End month 2: $4,033.75 + $30.25 = $4,064 So on until 11 months it is paid off and $176.95 is paid in interest.

So using the HYSA with 4.35% APY (my current situation) and saving to $5,000 with the $500 cash flow. $625 a week (averages to same interest as $1562.50 put in at start of month and accrues all month) and $2,000 withdrawn at the end of the month. For easy math let’s say

End of month 1: $500 + $5.66 (int) = $505.66 End of month 2: $1,005.66 + $7.50 = $1,013.16 So on until month 10 the HYSA will have $5,139.93 with of course $139.93 of gained money.

In this scenario you have the option of paying $176.95 for $5,000 at the start of the 11 months or waiting 10 months and having the $5,000 and gaining $139.93. Am I doing the math wrong or forgetting some fundamental of velocity banking? I understand if it is the last chunk I am paying towards a loan it will give more cashflow, but if it is simply $5,000 just in the middle of the payoff route then it would benefit me more to use hysa, correct?

EDIT: Based on the comments, it has been pointed out that I am comparing the LOC to the HYSA when instead I should be comparing (the LOC to the interest of the loan) versus (the HYSA to the interest of the loan). To do this we need to find out the APR of the LOC and HYSA

For the LOC the Total Interest Percentage (TIP) = total interest paid / original borrowed amount

$176.95 / $5,000 = 0.0354 or 3.54%

TIP to APR = (TIP * 365) / repayment period

(0.0354 * 365) / 335 (or 11 months) = 0.0385 or 3.85%

For HYSA -> $139.93 / $5,000 = 0.0280 or 2.80%

(0.0280 * 365) / 305 (or 10 months) = 0.0335 or 3.35%

Now that all the math is done: Due to putting all the paychecks into the LOC or the HYSA it is changing their APR to a way better number than originally given. So for this scenario, any loan with an interest rate under 3.35%, it would be more efficient to use the HYSA, as it will make money faster than interest accrued (in this scenario). Any loan with an interest rate over 3.85%, it would be more efficient to use the LOC as it will accrue interest slower than the loans (in this scenario).

— 0