RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/victoria3 • … • u/MthrfcknNanuq

Spread out to satisfy MAPI or specialize?

Hi, which method is better at the start and then in the long run?

For example I have started tinkering with Prussia, but played Spain and US before that and I had mixed results from both. As Spain, I built up construction sectors to max in Navarra and Castille over the course of 30 years and slowly expanded the resources in other states in order to not go too overboard with the infrastructure and pop requirements at the same place, as building railways for 20 inf gains took too long in my opinion and not really effective. But my economy crashed shortly after reaching 200 construction as goods became so expensive despite having a massive resource industry (or as big as it can be in case of lumber) that I went into a debt spiral, even importing could not help despite being hugely profitable.

I found a comment here stating that for early game pms, with iron frame construction, 2 construction sectors+2 lumbermills+3 iron mines on atmospheric engine+1 tooling workshop (plus 2 coal mines if my calculation is right) creates a good closed loop in one state that should keep mapi down in theory, at the cost of 40k pops and 40(?) infrastructure. However doing this, I'm losing out of troughput bonuses at first, and then repeating this cycle needs a lot of railway infrastructure, which takes a long time to build, which requires iron coal steeln and motor industries which take even longer to build, slowing down my overall growth.

So the question is, which method should I go with? Is it better to specialize states at first to certain resources that they have natural bonuses on and take advantage of troughput but suffer mapi, or satisfy mapi and take it slow but steady? Mainly in relation to Prussia, but I guess the method is applicable to all countries with good industrial potential.

— 0