Thoughts on the Turtle Island flag
After \~400 hours, I'm beginning to learn how to play Vicky 3. I decided to try a tougher start so I started as the Hudson Bay Company to release and play Métis as a subject of the HBC. I managed to bully the HBC into increasing my autonomy, then convinced the UK to beat up the USA for me over time. I wasn't planning on forming Turtle Island, but the opportunity arose and I figured why not.
Unfortunately, the flag for Turtle Island is based on a symbol created by a pretendian in the 1970s. Charles Storm (aka Hyemeyohsts Storm) was the son of a German immigrant who claimed to be Cheyenne. He invented the symbol, based off the stone circles associated with Indigenous peoples of the Great Plains. Although it isn't uncommon for Indigenous people to mistakenly use the symbol, the stylized medicine wheel reinforces the misappropriation and commodification of Indigenous cultures. So much pre-contact culture has been purposefully erased through settler-colonial policies of dispossession, eradication, and assimilation. It would be a shame to continue to allow settlers to control Indigenous symbols of identity. There really aren't any Pan-Indigenous symbols, due to the fact that Indigenous nations across Turtle Island are incredibly diverse.
I would suggest either leaving the flag of the previous tag even after forming Turtle Island (I suspect that this tag isn't high up on anyone's priority list so this would be a relatively easy solution) or using the Two Row Wampum flag, which is a symbol actually created by Indigenous people and symbolizes an adaptation of Indigenous ways of being (I would argue in a healthy and positive way) to the arrival of settlers. If Turtle Island were to be created in this timeline, the nation would necessarily have to reconcile with the introduction of European ideas of governance and economy (it also makes it easier to role play as a united Indigenous nation that has the Industrialists in power).
Of the Two Row Wampum flag:
"One row symbolizes the Haudenosaunee people with their law and customs, while the other row symbolizes European laws and customs. As nations move together side-by-side on the River of Life, they are to avoid overlapping or interfering with one another." -John Borrows, Indigenous legal scholar