Is Bioshock Infinite a Good Game?

So, between college assignments and work shifts, I have decided to start a personal project on a video game that has been on my mind for the past 4 months: BioShock Infinite. The goal of this project is to determine once and for all, in no uncertain terms, whether this game truly deserves the title of underapreciated masterpiece or overrated trashterpiece, and the first phase of the project involves gathering as much information as I can about the thoughts, opinions, and analyses of every person I can find so as to ensure I understand all of the good and all of the bad without missing a single degail, and I want your input. So, my fellow Redditors, would you kindly give me your stance on the matter?