Should the Silent Protagonist finally be put to rest going forward?
It is currently 2026 and with me just completing Ace Combat 8, the game poses character interactions to the player in Yes/No responses and the supporting cast fill the air like you said something profound. To me any sort of Silent Protagonist who sort of only speaks through text doesn't immerse me more into the game it takes me out of it. Sure their are characters and instances that lend themselves to a Silent Protagonist where it wouldn't make much sense to have them speak than not e.g: Elden Ring, Legend of Zelda, Doom, etc. That then poses the question to all of you, do you like the Silent Protagonist trope or do you think it should be done away with?