RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/violinist • … • u/schrodinger_s_kitten

why are people afraid of second position?

I've never understood that. Second position is extremely useful and I use it all the time (albeit a bit out of tune since I'm not so good at higher positions yet), but I talk abt it to other student violinists, most more advanced than me, and they go "noo its hard n stuff just go to third/do a finger extension". They go to ridiculous lengths to avoid it, like constantly shifting back and forth between 1st and 3rd pos in a passage that would be much easier and practical in 2nd pos. It's like they don't even consider it. The argument I've heard is that "the finger spacing between 1 & 3 is p different but 2 is in kind of a weird midway" and I'm like bitch what??? by that logic 4th position should be even worse but I don't see anyone complaining about it. why is this a thing?? I just don't understand. sorry for the ranting it's just a bit of a frustration of mine.

e: ok holy crap this got a lot of answers with a lot of good points and I'm learning a lot. thanks everyone!

— 0