RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/visualnovels • … • u/Resh_IX

I finished Umineko and I didn’t think it was a masterpiece

The biggest thing that killed my enjoyment of this VN was the pacing. I almost dropped the VN and switched to the manga reading the Questions Arc. There was so much repetition of plot points and constant regurgitated character dialogue. I honestly couldn’t emotionally connect with any of the characters situations since any sense of loss was null and void since I knew characters were just gonna pop back up in the next episode.

The only episodes that I could genuinely say had me hooked was Episode 5 and Episode 7. Everything else was just okay? Good, but in no way a masterpiece. A mix of 6/10’s, 7/10’s, and 8/10’s. This wasn’t my first VN, but I’ve seen a lot of people recommend Umineko for newcomers and I think they’re out of their mind. I know I have a lot of patience, but I don’t see anyone new to the medium surviving through the Question’s Arc. If I could get my time back I would’ve just read the manga for the questions arc, because getting through that was a massive slog with little to no pay offs. Every episode in the questions arc ended going right back to where we started. Felt like the story was going nowhere. That entire arc was unnecessarily long.

— 0