RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/vtm • … • u/djasonwright

Trust and Reputation

>TL;DR: I assign each player a ***Trust Rating*** from 0 to 5 for each NPC. This tells me - at a glance - what that NPC thinks of the PC, and how much they're willing to work with them as well as whether or not favors they can do for that NPC are available.

I have a real problem coming up with - for lack of a better word - plots. How do I get my players' characters entangled in the world of Kindred life and politics, without falling back on sect violence, serial killers that might be vampires, or the all the other old cliches? And there are so many "major" NPCs in a city run by vampires. How do I keep track of them all, and their relationships with coterie?

When I can, I try to use **Ambition** and **Desire** to direct my preparation for running Vampire. I tell my players that these (along with Convictions) are their way of telling me what they want to see in the game - the sorts of stories they want their characters to get involved in. Unfortunately, even knowing this, sometimes players show up to the game in a completely different frame of mind than when they created their characters. Sometimes, Players are just non-starters. They don't know what to do in a sandbox game (which is how I view Vampire). They get paralyzed by the choices or lack of direction, and it can be exceedingly difficult to encourage them to "get behind the wheel" of their character and direct their stories. Especially if they're coming from D&D.

Before I get into how I've started making this easier on myself as the Storyteller, I should confess that I am absolutely addicted to worldbuilding. My hobby is creating NPCs, creating Locations, thinking up plot ideas and where to stick them in my city. A lot of these will be renamed, reskinned, or rekajiggered to fit into the expectations of the Players. When one of them creates a Contact or an Ally, or a Touchstone, Mentor, Enemy, etc., I've got this stable of characters to draw from. I take the one that's closest to what the Player gave me, scratch off the serial numbers and recreate them as that Player's NPC. A lot of times, I do this with the NPCs presented in books like ***Chicago by Night*** or ***Fall of London***.

Once I've got an NPC, I also give each Player Character a "Trust Level" with that character. This is just a rating, from 1 to 5, that governs how likely the NPC is to work with a Player Character - how well the PC has integrated themselves into the NPC's life and world. Most NPCs start at Trust 1, though Enemies begin at 0, and a character like a Mawla or a Sire might start at 2 Trust. Backgrounds like Fame or Status might make it easier to raise or lower Trust - a lot of it is just done by "feel".

I record this with the PC's name and 1 to 5 dots in the Notes section of the character sheet (e.g. Soleil Blaise XXOOO), or just in the margins or something. The Coterie's Trust Level with a given NPC is equal to the highest trust in the group, minus 1; or minus 2 if that character isn't present.

Basically, this governs how likely the NPC is to accept the PC as an equal - or at least as an ally.

Because I'm insane, each level of Trust also has an associated "quest" - a task or story beat - associated with it; a way for the PCs to further ingratiate themselves with the character in question. I don't usually flesh these out more than a beginning, middle, and end - kind of like the barest bones of an idea for a story. Just to give me a starting point when I'm sitting down to prepare for the next session (or - when things go completely off the rails - so I'm less likely to be totally unprepared when I'm flying by the seat of my pants because I had no idea the players would do that!).

As an example, I had a Player whose ambition was (basically) to attain Golconda, so I put an NPC in place who - if they nurtured the right relationship with her - could help them along that path.

* At Trust 1 (provided the PC had expressed interest in Golconda, or enlightenment, etc), she'd approach the PC during a quiet moment, to discuss enlightenment. However, a rival Kindred who wants to discredit this NPC interrupts the conversation (this presumably happens at Elysium). The PC chooses to defend the NPC's philosophy, remain neutral, or align with the skeptic (fail condition for the whole questline); but if they demonstrate genuine interest and willing to defend their own beliefs or curiosity, she rewards the PC with a basic lesson in controlling the Beast - likely a week or more of instruction to allow the PC to purchase a single dot in the Lore Sheet "Golconda", when they can afford it. * At Trust 2, the NPC introduces the PC to a mortal cult whose tenets closely reflect the teaching of the Master of Ravens, through the lens of the living. The gathering is disrupted by a misguided do-gooder seeking to expose the cult's fraudulent teachings. If the PCs successfully diffuse the situation, the NPC might offer them a minor Boon, and they can continue to delve deeper into the insights provided by the cult. If not, the cult likely relocates - perhaps the NPC as well. * At Trust 3, this particular NPC needed her own teacher, and would task the PC with locating a wandering healer, who seems to be a Kindred, but avoids kindred society. This healer would turn out to be an elder Salubri, but the meeting was complicated by a local Baron demanding favor in exchange for permission to operate within his domain. This also had the potential of spooking the Salubri who might then completely evade the PC. Success would mean a brief meeting between the NPC and the Salubri, who might impart cryptic wisdom before departing. Failure might not negatively impact Trust with the NPC, but would lead to her expressing frustration. * Trust 4, was basically The Raid, or Dredd, but with Vampires. In Miami. But the NPC and the PC / Coterie would be trying their best not to cause unwarranted death or violence. * Trust 5 would be endgame with this NPC, who would - hopefully - transcend their vampiric condition, and seek to extricate themselves from Kindred society. Complications might include SI interference or perhaps another Kindred fearful of a Masquerade breach. The PC would witness the change in the NPC, and then choose whether to step into the role of mentor and teacher, or walk away, carrying the knowledge of what they witnessed. Or the NPC might die, failing to attain their goal and demonstrating to the PC the frailty of the quest for redemption. I'm always torn on which is worst: giving the PCs hope knowing it will (practically) never work out, or just showing them it will never work out.

This is the system I've started using to keep track of the PC's reputation with each of the Kindred, and some Factions, in the city. I find it works as shorthand and lets me - at a glance - know what a particular NPC thinks of the Player's character.

I always think I'm probably doing WAY too much; and I won't disagree if you tell me so here; but I thought it might be helpful to other STs.

— 0