My rant about the Gilneas storyline.
So the Forsaken sack their city. Murder 100s of them and raise them as undead. Force them to flee to the Alliance. Betray them when they have to work together for the good of Azeroth. Then burn down their new closest allies city (their new home). And then the forsaken just give back the city? Hell even help them reclaim it? Like wtf!
I know they aren't actively at war at this point. But Gilneas is a huge tactical advantage! An alliance city separating Undercity and Silvermoon is a crazy thing for the Horde to allow to happen.
Also Genn giving up the crown feels like a cheap move. He is a flawed, somewhat unlikable character. But at least he is a character. And not "Daddy please notice me".
After we finish the questline, what's our reward? we get a rubbish transmog, and a fox. Why a fox? Like have we ever seen Gilneans riding foxes?
The only redeeming thing for me the is Scarlet Crusade. Who are one of my favorite villains, i wish they came up more. Like they are evil, but not a legion level threat. Proper down to earth adventuring.
​
What it should have been is an awesome display of force! It should have been forsaken forces pulling out as per some agreement they aren't happy with. But maybe a rogue faction stay behind. They settled there. This is where they live after what happened to Under city. So the combined Night elf / Worgan forces fight their way back into the city. In a heroic push to finally take back Gilneas for the Alliance. If the writers wanted to get rid of Genn so much, he could have been killed of in the climactic battle.
Or better yet.... the forsaken don't pull out. And a rogue group (Genn + some night elves + secret Si7 backing) take the city by force without telling the major Alliance leaders. Weakened Forsaken forces loose in a bloody and decisive battle with the Worgan. Key Worgan lore characters are re-introduced, given some lines, and setup as badass characters . This would be a perfect way to re-introduce hostility between Horde and Alliance (doesn't have to be all out war). It re-affirms that the Alliance is not always the good guys. Gives the players some nice revenge on the Forsaken. And again, if Genn needs to be removed, *Turalyon* could always remove him as leader for going behind his back or something. Sets up some distrust in the Alliance, possible catalyst for future stories.
​
Rewards wise. It would be cool to have a better transmog set. But what would be really cool is..... option for Gilneas humans (non-cursed). Maybe even Pack form skins for the druid shapeshifts. I'd love to tank as an actual werewolf, using claws and shit, then switch back to my normal form for casting.
I know this would mean Horde couldn't play. But there is always the "recount events from the other sides perspective" thing. Hell you could even make it so Alliance chars do the same thing, and play the questline as a Worgan berserker rather than your player character.