Ghirbi the Lock: a theory on why he cannot rise higher.
Any good gatekeeper knows you don't leave a key in the lock. It defeats the purpose of the lock if it always has the key and can always be opened by anyone. Therefore, while a lock will always hold the *shape* of its key, it doesn't hold the key for longer than necessary.
In the case of the Stag Door, the lock is Ghirbi. The shape of his keys are the riddles. The keys that fit these shapes are the answers. As the lock on the door he once failed to breach, he will always hold the shape of the keys, but he will not hold the keys for longer than necessary.
Therein lies the true punishment for his trespasses.
Every time one rises to become Know, he obtains the key: an answer to one of the Stag Door's riddles.
Every time, he learns how to open the gate he could never pass.
Every time, the Horned Axe *permits* the acolyte to pass the Stag Door's threshold.
Every time, the Horned Axe *forbids* the riddle's answers passage into Ghirbi's memory.
Every time, Ghirbi feels the key leave him , like a memory of a dream fading in the morning.
Every time, the door closes to him, for he does not know how to open it.
Every time, he weeps.