Smaller-sized venue w/ a surprising catering minimum - does this add up?
I tried to make the title concise, but essentially my fiancé and I have our hearts set on a venue that can only cater up to 100 guests. This is perfect for us as we were hoping to have a smaller guest list anyway, while hopefully saving some money in the process. We have an 8 month old son and while he is our main priority, we are hoping to have (and responsibly afford) the special day we’ve always wanted.
Now to the details — our venue, a combo hotel/restaurant, has a strict maximum guest count of 100 guests, but their menus/minimum spend amount just aren’t adding up to us. Their cheapest option for all food/open bar combined is $139/person, and the option we’re looking to do is $169/person. We were comfortable with this until we learned they have a $14k minimum spend before taxes/gratuity.
We want to have 80 guests. 80 guests x $169 is $13,520… which still comes in below their minimum. If we wanted to go cheaper (the $139 price), 80 guests would only get to $11,120! If we maxed out the guest list to 100 people at the $139 rate, we would come in *just* below at $13,900. We feel like $14k is too high for the size of wedding they cater to — smaller, more intimate setting.
This situation is frustrating to my fiancé because he feels we’re being pressured into a wedding of a certain size and food of a certain scale just to meet this minimum.
I do want to mention that this $14,000 catering service includes ALL rentals — custom tent, tables, chairs, linens, staff, bathrooms, you name it. I feel like that could be enough to make it worth the minimum regardless, but maybe I’m biased since I love the venue.
Should we just accept the weird pricing structure due to all the all-inclusive convenience this venue offers, or should we ask for flexibility on the minimum?