RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/whatcarshouldIbuy • … • u/RapidPipetter

New Civic Hybrid Hatchback Sport vs Prius PHEV SE

By all accounts, both are great cars. Prius PHEV SE costs more (\~35k vs \~32, close to MSRP values) but with the rebate in my state (3k) plus additional fuel savings it should even out. I'm having a hard time deciding and would appreciate owners' and experts' perspectives. Here are the details:

\- 20-25k miles/year driver. I commute \~40mi to work. Eastern seaboard USA climate so I expect to drive in cold for 1 season and snow a few times a year. Gonna get snow tires so not too concerned about AWD.

\- 250V fast charging is available at home for PHEV. So with the PHEV it would only be burning gas otw home from work

\- In choosing these vehicles as my top options I prioritized fuel economy for saving $, time spent at gas stations, and the environment. This is partly why I chose the lowest trims available for both hybrid options, as the higher trims get worse economy due to larger wheels/AWD

\- 90-95% of the time (given how many commuting hours I have) I'm driving just me at 65-75 on the highway. 5-10% me + wife. <1% anyone else. So, backseat is not much concern. Little ones are in the plans but not here yet, this car has to be able to handle baby + gear (which I'm sure both can, not currently concerned on this)

\- Both options are stretching my budget, so I'm not interest in anything more expensive.

What do y'all think?

— 0