RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/whatcarshouldIbuy • … • u/PermRecDotCom

Alternative to Forester for: manual + AWD/4WD + roadtrips + rough trailheads + daily driver

I have a Subaru Forester and it generally works OK for my uses: the occasional long road trip (100s or 1000s of cumulative miles), plus a daily driver, plus getting to remote trailheads. Now, due to issues like needing a new (California-compliant) catalytic converter, I'm looking for an alternative:

1. Must be AWD or 4WD. Not a rock crawler, but able to get at least partway up rough trailhead roads.

2. I think any form of automatic transmission would drive me nuts, so manual is a 99.99% requirement.

3. Reliable, for daily use.

4. Something that has a sleeping area in the back.

On a recent road trip to Colorado, I had to park at the lowest parking for Sneffels because it couldn't get to the first parking lot. It could only make it about 1/2 a mile up the 4WD road to the Elbert trailhead (the one near Lakeview Campground). It did make it to the top parking lot for Handies. On a previous trip, it made it to Kite Lake. On the road, it struggled on some of the steep passes so a little oomph would have been appreciated.

I don't think a Jeep Wrangler is an option due to noise, vibration, MPG, etc. I'd worry about getting a Fix Or Repair Daily. A Toyota might be an option, but I'd have to add a shell. And, all of those suck at MPG. That's a secondary concern but in CO with 87 gas the Forester was getting over 30 MPG for long stretches.

Should I just get another Forester?

— 0