Scifi short story from 80s or earlier, inventor had a portal used for garbage disposal, suddenly something came back through
When I was young, someone was reading me a story where a man had invented some kind of device you could put things in and they would go away, perhaps to another dimension. He couldn't find business opportunities with it, so he had a large one in his workshop with no door on it that he used as a garbage disposal, until one day something came back *out* of the device.
The person reading the story was interrupted at that point and never got a chance to get back to it. Anyone know what story that is? Based on the style and language, I'd guess it was from the 50s or 60s.