Secret Teenage Witchcraft Book?
Ok, here's all I remember. This is driving me crazy.
Cover: Teenage witch standing over a glowing cauldron, possibly second older witch standing over her shoulder. The background is quite dark, teen girl has either black or brown hair, and a shocked expression. Cauldron is glowing a purplish colour.
Publication Date: No later than mid 2000s, probably not much earlier than late 80s/early 90s. I would have read this sometime between 2001 and 2005 in Canada. Believe this was a standalone book, not a series.
Setting: Small medieval village/farm
Plot Points: - teen girl learning to be a witch from an older mentor (possibly a relative?) - secrecy of magic - persecution of witches - romance between teen witch and non magical boy - forced into moral dilemma to risk exposure to help others (possibly the boy she likes?)