Bit of a hard/subjective one: £2400 with Ti frame + SRAM Force XPLR AXS 1x12 or ~£1500 with AL frame + 105?
So, the situation I'm in is that I want a gravel bike with at minimum 105/GRX600, hydraulic disc brakes, and tyre clearances of at least 40mm. I don't have a strong frame material preference, although I think I want to avoid carbon as I intend to ride this bike hard off-road and will probably be crashing a fair bit.
105/GRX600 + hydro discs start at around £1500 on alloy frame and carbon fork bikes, but I've also gotten the opportunity to get the Planet X Tempest Ti with XPLR AXS for £2400 at this spec:

The spec on the Tempest is pretty equivalent to most \~£1500 bikes aside from the titanium frame and Force XPLR groupset, so my worry is that I'll regret paying the £900 premium for those.
105/GRX600 on an alloy frame is obviously the more financially sound decision as I know what to expect from that combination and the £900 savings will make it viable to get N+1 in a year or two rather than 3+, *however,* it seems unlikely that I'll get such a good deal on a Force XPLR AXS level groupset anytime soon, and the titanium frame is a nice bonus too.
The only other option that's remotely close is the Canyon Grail AL with AXS XPLR for 2249, but that 150 saving is lost because Canyon is exclusive to Cyclescheme, whereas Planet X accepts the scheme I have access to (Green Commute Initiative). I also want something other than alloy if I'm spending that much, tbh.
For the sake of comparison, my shortlist of bikes I'd get if I decide against the Tempest are (in my order of preference):
1. 1499 - [Sonder Camino](https://alpkit.com/products/sonder-camino-al-v3-grx1) (Alloy, GRX600/400 mix) 2. 1499 - [Ribble CGR AL](https://www.ribblecycles.co.uk/ribble-cgr-al-orange-sram-apex/?childSku=BBCGRAOR145) (Alloy, Apex 1x11) (or 1650 with nicer 650B wheels) 3. 1649 - [Cube Nuroad Ex](https://www.cube.eu/uk-en/cube-nuroad-ex-flashstone-n-orange/580150) (Alloy, GRX400/600/812 mix) 4. ~~1449 - Canyon~~ [~~Grizl~~](https://www.canyon.com/en-gb/gravel-bikes/bike-packing/grizl/al/grizl-6/2708.html?dwvar_2708_pv_rahmenfarbe=GN) ~~or~~ [~~Grail~~](https://www.canyon.com/en-gb/gravel-bikes/all-road/grail/al/grail-6/3092.html?dwvar_3092_pv_rahmenfarbe=YE%2FBK) ~~(GRX 400, but better wheels than the above)~~
The Camino and CGR AL are my top picks, or the CGR 725 if it goes on sale again (I refuse to get the base spec 1499 model with Tiagra). I like the spec of these 3 bikes, and both Sonder and Ribble would allow me to switch for 650B wheels which would suit my 162cm/5'4" ass. The sidegrade to 650 would be free on the Sonder, whereas the only option for Ribble is an upgrade to the Mavic Allroad 650B for 150GBP (seems worthwhile as it's -250G off the default spec Aksium 700C).
The Grail and Grizl were also in contention, but being unable to get them on a bike to work scheme is a dealbreaker as that's a \~32% savings lost.
\---
So, what do y'all think? Does the Tempest at the above spec seem worth the extra £900, or should I go for the more sensible £1500 option with a bike like the Camino for the flexibility it allows me in getting a second bike much sooner, or upgrading the wheelset, buying an indoor trainer, etc.?
I keep talking myself into and out of both options so I'm open to points on either side. The points I keep bringing up in my head:
|Tempest|Camino| |:-|:-| |2400 is a great deal for Force AXS + titanium|1500 gravel bike + \~1000 HT MTB in a year or so > 2400 gravel bike?| |Titanium should last forever if I take care of it|I'll get bored of the frameset and want something different long before Alloy durability/longevity becomes an issue| |I prefer the Tempest aesthetically|1500 cost opens up space in the budget to invest in nicer wheels which could be carried forward to future builds|
So yeah, the Camino seems like the sensible choice with less downside/regret, but I've also got some serious FOMO regarding titanium and wireless shifting that are making me consider the Tempest. It's got a higher ceiling of enjoyment, but also a lower floor of regret if I end up not loving the frameset (which is an issue because I can't test ride it given the direct to consumer model). Thoughts? I'm super indecisive if you couldn't tell...
I'm also open to other bikes of equivalent spec to the Camino in the £1400-1600 price category. To go any higher I would need a special draw such as a Ti, nice carbon, or high-end steel frame, or of course wireless shifting.