Who Would Be In Your All-Time White Sox Lineup?
If you had to put together a lineup of your favorite players for the White Sox, who would be in it? You can set your own parameters (only over the last few seasons, modern era, All Time, players you liked, players you thought were the best, players that were statistically the best, etc). For me, I'll include all White Sox players and pick a specific season/version of the player I choose - basing it on a mix of statistics and my fandom/opinion on the players. I also included a full rotation of 5 starters and a closer. This is the first lineup I've done that included almost 120 years of team history, so there's a chance it ends up being a huge mess...but I think I'll probably lean towards the modern era ('50s-'60s to present) since I'm more familiar with it.
This will be my 21st team "All Time Lineup" that I have put together. It started as an interesting discussion topic on the Rockies sub (where I was traded during Reddit Trade Deadline), and I've enjoyed putting it together for the teams I have done so far, so I figured I'll just keep going.
​
Here's my lineup:
1. SS Luke Appling R - 1936 season: .388/.474/.508 (.981 OPS/142 wRC+), 6 HR, 128 RBI, & 10 SB 2. 2B Eddie Collins L - 1915 season: .332/.460/.436 (.896 OPS/169 wRC+), 4 HR, 118 R, 77 RBI, & 46 SB 3. DH Frank Thomas R - 1994 season: .353/.487/.729 (1.217 OPS/205 wRC+), 38 HR & 101 RBI 4. 1B Paul Konerko R - 2010 season: .312/.393/.584 (.977 OPS/158 wRC+), 39 HR & 111 RBI 5. LF Minnie Minoso R - 1954 season: .320/.411/.535 (.946 OPS/158 wRC+), 19 HR, 116 RBI, & 18 SB 6. RF Magglio Ordonez R - 2002 season: .320/.381/.597 (.978 OPS/155 wRC+), 38 HR, 135 RBI, & 7 SB 7. CF Harold Baines L - 1984 season: .304/.361/.541 (.903 OPS/143 wRC+), 29 HR & 94 RBI 8. C Carlton Fisk R - 1983 season: .289/.355/.518 (.874 OPS/137 wRC+), 26 HR, 86 RBI, & 9 SB 9. 3B Robin Ventura L - 1996 season: .287/.368/.520 (.888 OPS/122 wRC+), 34 HR & 105 RBI
​
* SP Ed Walsh R - 1908 season: 40-15 with a 1.42 ERA, 0.86 WHIP, & 269 K in 49 GS/66 G/464 IP * SP Ted Lyons R - 1927 season: 22-14 with a 2.84 ERA, 1.16 WHIP, & 71 K in 34 GS/39 G/307.2 IP * SP Billy Pierce L - 1955 season: 15-10 with a 1.97 ERA, 1.10 WHIP, & 157 K in 26 GS/33 G/205.2 IP * SP Mark Buehrle L - 2005 season: 16-8 with a 3.12 ERA, 1.18 WHIP, 149 K in 33 GS/236.2 IP * SP Chris Sale L - 2014 season: 12-4 with a 2.17 ERA, 0.97 WHIP, & 208 K in 26 GS/174 IP * CP Hoyt Wilhelm R - 1965 season: 7-7, 21 SV/3 BS with a 1.81 ERA, 0.83 WHIP, & 106 K in 66 G/144 IP
​
* Manager Ozzie Guillen: 687-617 (52.4%), 2 playoff appearances, 1 World Series Championship
​
Here is some of the reasoning behind my choices:
* C Fisk: Ray Shalk is a Hall of Famer on the strength of his defense and durability, and Pierzynski had over 1000 hits with the team and 1 All Star appearance. For some reason, Ron Karkovice sticks out in my mind from the '90s, but he was just an average player statistically. This is between Carlton Fisk and Sherm Lollar to me. Sherm Lollar was an 8x All Star and 3x Gold Glover who was an above average hitter (career 108 wRC+), while Fisk is a 4x All Star for Chicago with a career 108 wRC+. Fisk gets the nod because he's a Hall of Famer who spent more than half his career with the team. * 1B Konerko: Paul Konerko was a 6 time All Star and part of the 2005 WS winning team, helping immensely by hitting well in all 3 rounds and winning ALCS MVP. His number is retired by the team and he's top 4 in franchise history in H (3rd), 2B (3rd), HR (2nd), R (4th), RBI (2nd), and BB (4th). Frank Thomas split his time close to 50/50 between 1B and DH, but wasn't a good fielder so I'm using him at DH - read more about him there. Jose Abreu is a Rookie of the Year and 3x All Star and has never had fewer than 22 HR. Earl Sheely, Zeke Bonura, and Shano Collins were good players in the earlier years of the franchise as well. Interestingly, Dick Allen only played 3 seasons with the team but made a big impact - winning an MVP award, 3 All Star selections, the best 1B season by fWAR in Sox history, and a 181 wRC+ for his White Sox career. Had he played a few more seasons, maybe he gets this spot over Konerko. * 2B Collins: Ray Durham was a 2x All Star who had a nice career with the team before playing for SF, but this comes down to Nellie Fox and Eddie Collins. Both are Hall of Famers, while Nellie Fox has his number retired and went to 15 All Star games, winning 3 Gold Gloves, Collins retired in 1930, before numbers were used and All Star Games/Gold Gloves were established. Collins has roughly a 20 WAR lead over Fox per FanGraphs and Baseball-Reference for Chicago, but Fox won his MVP award with the team. I went with Collins here because he was a better offensive player compared to his era, though it seems like a toss-up to me. * 3B Ventura: Pete Ward received MVP consideration his first 2 seasons, Bill Melton hit 20+ HR in 5 different seasons and made 1 All Star game, and Joe Crede had an All Star appearance, a couple good seasons, and was part of the WS winning team. Robin Ventura is the guy here, though. He won 5 Gold Gloves and made it to 1 All Star team in his 10 seasons with the team - on his way to leading all franchise 3B in fWAR by almost 16 (he had 39.2 for Chicago). * SS Appling: Luke Appling was a lifetime White Sox, all time franchise leader in fWAR and bWAR, a 7x All Star, and Hall of Famer with his number retired by the team. He has about 40 more WAR than the next best SS in franchise history...sometimes there is a judgement call to make when I'm putting these lineups together, and this is not one of those times. Appling was never a leadoff hitter, but I think that OBP works really well at the top of the lineup, so I put him there. This isn't to say there was nobody else that was a good SS in franchise history: Luis Aparicio is another Hall of Famer with his number retired by the team, won a Rookie of the Year, made 8 All Star appearances, won 7 Gold Glove awards, and was a league leader in SB for 7 straight years. George Davis is another Hall of Famer who played 5 seasons with the team. More recently, Jose Valentin had 5 good seasons with the team - never hitting fewer than 25 HR, and Alexei was an All Star and finished 2nd in RoY voting for Chicago. * LF Minoso: Minoso played 12 seasons with the team (though 2 of those were short appearances in his 50s that were likely publicity stunts because of Bill Veeck), and was nicknamed Mr. White Sox. He was a 6x All Star, 2x Gold Glover, and finished 4th in MVP voting 4 times as a White Sox. His number 9 is retired by the team. There were also several other good LF in team history: Carlos May was a 2x All Star, Carlos Lee had 150+ HR/550+ RBI in 6 seasons with the team, Tim Raines had 5 nice seasons later in his career for the team, and Albert Belle is hard not to mention, with his 79 HR in 2 seasons. Of course, Shoeless Joe Jackson spent basically 4 full seasons as a premiere player in the league - but his best seasons were with Cleveland. For what it's worth, btw, it looks like Jackson's stats were better in '19 (when he was supposedly throwing the WS) than they were in '17, when they actually won. * CF Baines: Fielder Jones was a really good CF (and player/manager who won a WS) for a while; Johnny Mostil finished 2nd in MVP voting once; Tommie Agee was a 2x All Star, Gold Glover, and Rookie of the Year; and Jim Landis went to 2 All Star games and won 5 Gold Glove awards. More recent guys like Adam Eaton, Aaron Rowand, and Chris Singleton were memorable as well. I should have gone with Chet Lemon, who made 2 All Star games in 7 seasons, and had an OPS over .815 for his Chicago career - but I'm sort of cheating here and using Baines in CF, since he played 20 games in CF in '83, then 7 in '84. He's a Hall of Famer who in total spent 14 seasons with the team and made 4 All Star teams. * RF Ordonez: Baines was primarily a RF then DH later in his career, but I snuck him in above to fit Ordonez in here. Carlos Quentin spent time in both LF and RF, hitting 21+ HR in each of his 4 seasons with the team and finishing his White Sox career with an .857 OPS and 2 All Star appearances. Jermaine Dye was a 1x All Star with a 44 HR/120 RBI season for Chicago, and he never hit less than 27 HR in his 5 years with the team and won a WS MVP award. Magglio Ordonez made 4 All Star games and had 5 straight seasons of 29+ HR, and he's one of the most memorable White Sox players for me, so I couldn't leave him off. * DH Thomas: The Big Hurt was a White Sox legend - he finished Top 8 in MVP voting 8 times, winning back-to-back MVP awards in '93-'94. He won a batting title, and was named to 5 All Star teams in his 16 seasons with the White Sox. He's a Hall of Famer with his number 35 retired by the team. Frank Thomas had 12 seasons with a OPS over .900 and 8 straight seasons of .975 or higher to start his career, with the franchise record for HR (448), RBI (1465), R (1327), 2B (447), and BB (1466). His most dominant year was 1994, which was shortened by the strike. Jim Thome gets some consideration here, but he was only with the team for 3 and a half seasons. He did make it to one All Star game. Hall of Famer Harold Baines also spent quite a bit time at DH as well, and I could have used him here instead. * SP Walsh: Ed Walsh is hard to leave off this list for one simple fact: his 1.82 career ERA is the all time leader in ERA for anyone in the history of the MLB with more than 100 innings pitched - this shows he was dominant even relative to the lesser offenses from 100+ years ago. Walsh was a spitballer with great control who won 2 games in the 1906 WS and had a no hitter in 1911. He pitched before Cy Young awards and All Star games, so he has less recognition than recent guys, only accruing his Hall of Fame induction, 2 ERA titles, and a couple of 2nd place finishes in MVP voting. Arm injuries/pain pretty much ended his career at 31-32, preventing him from pitching significant innings ever again. * SP Lyons: Ted Lyons is a Hall of Famer with his number 16 retired by the team. He was a lifetime Chicago White Sox player who holds the team record for career wins with 260 and had a no hitter in 1926. I read multiple places that he changed his pitching style from fastballs to curves and knuckleballs later in his career due to arm troubles, and he only started around 20-24 games a year in the '30s because he was the biggest draw on a bad team and started only on Sundays. He left for military service in WWII and came back at 45 years old to pitch a few games. * SP Pierce: Billy Pierce made 7 All Star games in the '50s and has his number retired by the team. He has the most wins of anybody who pitched in the 1950s or more recently for the franchise with 186, and won 15 or more games in 7 different seasons. * SP Buehrle: Mark Buehrle is a 4 time All Star and 3 time Gold Glover who helped the team win a WS in 2005 with arguably his best seasons for Chicago. His number 56 is retired by the club, and he has both a perfect game and a no hitter to his name. * SP Sale: Chris Sale went to 5 straight All Star games and finished top 6 in Cy Young voting for 5 consecutive years - basically every year he was a full time starter. He has a career 3.00 ERA as a White Sox player - I don't think he has quite the resume as some of the other guys (only 79 wins with the team and 9th in pitcher fWAR/10th in bWAR), but he's probably the most dominant pitcher for the White Sox in the last few decades. * SPs not included: This is where 119 seasons become a problem. There are just so many starters who could make this list, especially considering that 100 years ago offenses weren't what they are now, so pitchers from before 1950 or so seem statistically more impressive. Red Faber is a Hall of Famer who helped win the 1917 WS and is 2nd in franchise history with 256 wins, but I didn't want to overload the team with guys from really long ago so I picked Lyons over him. Early Wynn is a Hall of Famer who spent 5 seasons with the team and won a Cy Young award. Both Black Jack McDowell (3x All Star) and LaMarr Hoyt (1x All Star) were Cy Young award winners. Other guys from a previous era who deserve some consideration: Eddie Cicotte, Doc White, Thornton Lee, and 3x All Star Wilbur Wood (he was a workhouse who was the last guy to start 45 games in a season). Recent guys like Wilson Alvarez, John Danks, and Jose Quintana put together good careers with the team as well. * CP Wilhelm: There were lots of options: Keith Foukle was a good reliever for several seasons, but only closed for a little over 2 seasons in Chicago. Wilbur Wood (3x All Star) was a reliever/closer for a few seasons and pitched exceptionally well before being moved into the rotation and receiving some All Star attention. Hall of Famer Goose Gossage (2x All Star) started his career in Chicago but was only a closer 1 season out of his 5 with the team. Roberto Hernandez (1x All Star) has 161 saves in his career with the White Sox. Bobby Jenks (2x All Star) is 2nd in career saves for the team, providing 2 40+ save seasons. Bobby Thigpen (1x All Star) is the franchise leader in saves with 201 and had a sub-2 ERA season in 1990. But I went with knuckleballer Hoyt Wilhelm because his 5 sub-2 ERA seasons, all at 40+ years old, are really impressive, and he's a Hall of Famer (the first ever relief pitcher in the HoF I believe). Hell, his HoF plaque even refers to him as "Baseball's Premiere Relief Pitcher" - can't argue with that. * Manager Guillen: There isn't one manager that really stands out. Jimmy Dykes has the franchise record for wins with 899, but his overall record was under .500. Al Lopez and Tony La Russa were both elected to the Hall of Fame as managers, Lopez winning more than half his games as a Chicago manager and La Russa less than 20%. Fielder Jones, Pants Rowland, and Ozzie Guillen are the only managers to win a World Series championship. I think I'll go with Ozzie Guillen - he's 3rd in franchise history in wins, is well over .500, and won a championship.
​
What do you guys think? The people I wish I could have fit into the lineup would be Nellie Fox, Dick Allen, and Luis Aparicio. I also probably should have had Faber or Wood in over someone like Sale, but I think the rotation still looks good. What lineup/rotation would you guys have?
​
I've decided to turn this into a "series" of sorts that I do of the different teams. Here are links to the other teams "All Time" Lineups that I will fill in as I go:
AL East
* [Baltimore Orioles](https://np.reddit.com/r/orioles/comments/csne4a/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_orioles_lineup/) * [Boston Red Sox](https://np.reddit.com/r/redsox/comments/cx7e6b/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_red_sox_lineup/) * [New York Yankees](https://np.reddit.com/r/NYYankees/comments/cxnu82/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_yankees_lineup/) * [Tampa Bay Rays](https://np.reddit.com/r/tampabayrays/comments/cgzehh/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_rays_lineup/) * [Toronto Blue Jays](https://np.reddit.com/r/Torontobluejays/comments/cjstfd/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_blue_jays_lineup/)
AL Central
* [Chicago White Sox](https://np.reddit.com/r/whitesox/comments/ct6ogh/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_white_sox_lineup/) * [Cleveland Indians](https://np.reddit.com/r/ClevelandIndians/comments/czrfqo/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_indians_lineup/) * [Detroit Tigers](https://np.reddit.com/r/motorcitykitties/comments/ctnwu7/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_tigers_lineup/) * [Kansas City Royals](https://np.reddit.com/r/KCRoyals/comments/cjz5o6/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_royals_lineup/) * [Minnesota Twins](https://np.reddit.com/r/minnesotatwins/comments/cpzoe8/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_twins_lineup/)
AL West
* [Houston Astros](https://np.reddit.com/r/Astros/comments/cmiwul/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_astros_lineup/) * [Los Angeles Angels](https://np.reddit.com/r/angelsbaseball/comments/cmx2bl/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_angels_lineup/) * [Oakland Athletics](https://np.reddit.com/r/OaklandAthletics/comments/cnv90f/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_oakland_athletics/) * [Seattle Mariners](https://np.reddit.com/r/Mariners/comments/chrq1r/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_mariners_lineup/) * [Texas Rangers](https://np.reddit.com/r/TexasRangers/comments/cnc7ls/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_rangers_lineup/)
NL East
* [Atlanta Braves](https://np.reddit.com/r/Braves/comments/cpj7dy/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_atlanta_braves_lineup/) * [Miami Marlins](https://np.reddit.com/r/letsgofish/comments/cfe27w/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_marlins_lineup/) * [New York Mets](https://np.reddit.com/r/NewYorkMets/comments/ckw1dp/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_mets_lineup/) * [Philadelphia Phillies](https://np.reddit.com/r/phillies/comments/cu3sso/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_phillies_lineup/) * [Washington Nationals](https://np.reddit.com/r/Nationals/comments/chcaer/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_nationals_lineup/)
NL Central
* [Chicago Cubs](https://np.reddit.com/r/CHICubs/comments/cwrzjv/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_cubs_lineup/) * [Cincinnati Reds](https://np.reddit.com/r/Reds/comments/czb86h/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_reds_lineup/) * [Milwaukee Brewers](https://np.reddit.com/r/Brewers/comments/ckg53k/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_brewers_lineup/) * [Pittsburgh Pirates](https://np.reddit.com/r/buccos/comments/cvuulp/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_pirates_lineup/) * [St Louis Cardinals](https://np.reddit.com/r/Cardinals/comments/cwboh7/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_cardinals_lineup/)
NL West
* [Arizona Diamondbacks](https://np.reddit.com/r/azdiamondbacks/comments/cgjf2y/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_diamondbacks_lineup/) * [Colorado Rockies](https://np.reddit.com/r/ColoradoRockies/comments/ceznwj/who_would_be_your_alltime_rockies_lineup/) * [Los Angeles Dodgers](https://np.reddit.com/r/Dodgers/comments/cqgo7w/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_los_angeles_dodgers/) * [San Diego Padres](https://np.reddit.com/r/Padres/comments/cjj28y/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_padres_lineup/) * [San Francisco Giants](https://np.reddit.com/r/SFGiants/comments/cqwtxr/who_would_be_in_your_alltime_san_francisco_giants/)
Note: Links to previous lineups are provided if you are interested, but it obviously isn't an invitation to troll other subs.