RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/whowouldwin • … • u/nairbeg

Cyberiad vs New Paradigm Daleks

I know that Cybermen vs Daleks has been done before, and it's always been pretty obviously the Daleks who win, given their peak abilities and the actual canonical match-up ending pretty strongly in their favor. What I'm curious about, though, is the match-up between both species' more recent iterations.

We know that Time War-era Daleks like the Cult of Skaro, the Dalek Emperor's army, and Davros's faction in the Medusa Cascade would absolutely thrash Cybus-brand Cybermen. Once the Daleks finally settled-in as a here-to-stay part of the non-Time War reality, however, they don't seem to have maintained their same level of threat: they certainly aren't pulling the kind of Time War feats like the multiverse-ending shenanigans of the Davros faction. The New Dalek Paradigm seems to get mired in smaller-scale tussles with future humans (a la Into the Dalek) or even alliances; they don't seem powerful enough to just thoroughly shatter intergalactic politics the way they used to. Admittedly though I have limited knowledge of Dalek history; it seems like the New Dalek Paradigm might have given way to a restored Dalek Empire set on Skaro again as of "The Witch's Familiar", presumably in response to the Paradigm's Parliament being destroyed in "Time of the Doctor".

To contrast, the Cyberiad of Hedgewick's World of Wonders looked like they had taken a massive level-up in terms of adaptability, becoming capable of assimilating non-humans with just a touch and rapidly upgrading against weaponry on-the-fly. They admittedly never got to re-establish themselves as a presence in the universe, though, having been wiped out by the Doctor & company on Hedgewick's planet. We'll admittedly have to extrapolate what the Cyberiad are capable of from a smaller sample size.

Anyhow, here're some competitions I have in mind:

1.) An enactment of Dalek Sec's claim in the Battle of Canary Wharf: one New Paradigm Dalek versus 5 million post-Hedgewick Cyberiad units.

2.) An alternate history of "Nightmare in Silver": The 3 million Cyberiad units originally on Hedgewick's planet w/ a successfully converted 11th Doctor -- or "Mr. Clever" -- versus the restored Dalek City of Skaro w/ Davros in an advisory role as seen in "The Witch's Familiar".

3.) Bonus round! Missy's hypothetical: the 12th Doctor is Time Lord Victorious-Lusted and accepts Missy's Nethersphere Cybermen to go and "save the people suffering in the Dalek camps". Can he & his Cybermen wipe out the restored Dalek Empire? This is admittedly a little tangential to the original prompt, since the Nethersphere Cybermen are a different faction from the Cyberiad, despite their similar physical appearance.

— 0