RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/whowouldwin • … • u/CherryNomad

What is the least capable person (from fiction or reality) who can successfully complete The Odyssey?

**Rules:**

* If the chosen person ("The Captain") canonically owns a ship, they get to bring it. Otherwise, they receive a ship from their setting or time period (for example, Blackbeard from real life would sail the Queen Anne, and Maverick from Top Gun would receive a Nimitz Class Supercarrier or whatever). * Aircraft are not allowed, but land vehicles are. * If the person receiving a ship from their time period would trivialise the challenge, then they are simply put in charge of the original twelve ships of Odysseus' men. * If The Captain canonically has a crew or a team, they get to bring those people along as well, but only their *subordinates*. Anyone who is of equal or greater standing within the group cannot be taken on the journey. * If The Captain has any knowledge of the original myth of The Odyssey, they lose that knowledge. It is replaced with the same knowledge that Odysseus had at the outset of his journey (i.e. a general awareness of what Sirens are, knowledge of Poseidon as a literal physical deity, etc) * The Captain is forced to encounter each of the challenges within The Odyssey and replicate some of Odysseus' actions, though the exact methods and context can be altered as they wish: * They are forced to enter Polyphemus' cave, steal a wheel of cheese, and make visual contact with Polyphemus. * They must at some point enter the realm of the Laestrygonians. * The same storms which waylaid Odysseus also affect The Captain's ship. * At least one member of the crew must hear the songs of the Sirens. * The crew are forced to spend a month on Helios' island, with his sacred cattle. * The Captain must meet with Circe and have a conversation with her. * The Captain must forage for food on the island of the Lotus Eaters. As a reminder, preexisting knowledge about the myth of The Odyssey is erased, so nobody in the crew would know what the lotus does. * They must sail through the strait where Scylla and Charybdis can be found. * Calypso can be ignored, as this impediment could not be overcome except through divine intervention. * The Captain must kill the one hundred suitors by the end. They get to do this with whatever crew they make it through the journey with. Keeping Telemachus alive and meeting with Penelope are not required. * "Least capable" refers to an aggregate of a person's abilities, intelligence, physical stats, and the technological sophistication of their ship. * While the original challenge was written with the intention of there only being one ship, you can include a fleet of twelve vessels if you want to be true to the original myth, or however many ships accompanied The Captain on their most famous expedition (e.g. 17 ships on Columbus' Second Voyage) * There is no divine intervention whatsoever except for the summoning of storms by Poseidon to devastate the fleet. If the cows of Helios are slaughtered, assume that Zeus strikes The Captain's ship(s) with lightning bolts with sufficient force to destroy a 17th century ship-of-the-line.

**Rounds:**

* R1: All threats are based on Homer's "The Odyssey" as depicted in the Epic Cycle * R2: All threats are based on Christopher Nolan's "The Odyssey" as released in 2026 * R3: All threats are based on Jorge Rivera-Herrans' "Epic: The Musical" as released between 2022 and 2024

— 0