RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/whowouldwin • … • u/LurkingFrogger

The one ring randomly appears in another universe. Can it be destroyed?

Sauron does not exist in this universe (except as the ring itself).

Randomly appears means that the one ring shows up in a random but inhabited place.

(Edit2: This is the one ring created at Mt. Doom in LOTR not one created in the destination universe.)

Three major parts to this as I see it:

1.) Is there anything powerful enough to destroy the one ring?

2.) Is there anyone who can strike the final blow?

3.) Can it be wrested away from whomever the ring has corrupted?

Edit: Minor thought:

4.) Would the one ring even be useful in X universe?

Edit3: Since a lot of people seem to miss the point of #2 I'll put this here to help stop reposting it in replies:

For point 2.) the question is not one of power but if the person can resist the ring in the moment when the ring is most powerful. For example NO ONE on middle earth could do it. It was only fate (Eur interfering) that Gollum grabbed the ring and fell that the ring was destroyed at the end of ROTK. The desire to use the one ring will overcome virtually anyone when they actually attempt to destroy it. Even if the one ring would normally take centuries for the ring to corrupt them normally it has enough influence in the moment the blow is to be struck that they don't follow through. Maybe they think they can use it, maybe they simply think it would be better to wait for the council of others, or maybe they think it should be hidden away to be used when people are wiser and better about to stave off its influence but for whatever reason they can't destroy it and they of course think it is their own idea.

Note: This includes Gandalf, Galadriel, and other beings in LOTR who are basically demi-gods on middle earth.

(Maybe I should just go make The One Ring respect thread...)

— 0