RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/wicked • … • u/Pravorious

Am I misreading Wicked: For Good?

So I just saw Wicked: For Good, and I’m honestly struggling with what this film wants to say.

The movie is *beautiful,* no doubt. Cynthia Erivo is phenomenal, Ariana is great, and yes I still cried—but thematically, I’m very confused.

Now, to be fair, I haven't listened to the Musical fully in quite some time so I may be unaware of differences and whatnot. I have also not read the book.

So...

The first film fires you up.

To me, it was about resisting fascism, challenging propaganda, standing up to corrupt systems. It sets up Elphaba as someone who’s gearing up to genuinely *fight* for the oppressed.

But then in Wicked: For Good... that doesn't really get paid off imo.

All that political momentum just fizzles out. Elphaba prepares for confrontation, for justice, for *something*, and then… she disappears. She fakes her death and leaves Oz instead of challenging the Wizard or changing anything about the system that harmed her.

It ends up feeling like the film is saying: “Trying to change the system won’t work."

Even if it’s unintentional, having Glinda be the one to start reform (while still not outing the Wizard's fakeness) made the film feel like it was saying that only those already perceived as “good” or socially acceptable can create real change, while people who’ve been “othered” from the start are doomed to be misunderstood, erased, or forced into the shadows no matter what they do.

It gave me this weird tonal whiplash.

Wicked says “fight fascism,” and For Good says “well… actually, you can’t win, so have your already well-liked friend make the change while you go into self-imposed exile.”

And also all that talk from Dr. Dillamond about History in the first film and how if we don't listen we are doomed to repeat it. And then For Good ends with no one knowing the actual history?

Hell, a little girl from Kansas came here and "killed a witch" and just left like everything was super cool.

Idk maybe I'm crazy but I'm a bit loss thematically.

— 0