Thoughts on the Graphic Novel
(This paragraph is skippable personal context) I’ve been a huge fan of Wicked (musical and first book, less so of the other books) for about 15 years. I’ve read the first book several times and read all 14 Baum books just to get all the references haha. I even prefer the book in many ways to the musical! But I was a bit too young for the book when I first read it (kind of a canon event), and as someone who runs an elementary school library, I have been wishing for a movie or musical novelization that is appropriate for that age group. I even emailed Gregory Maguire’s team to ask if he’s considered it because he’s a fantastic children’s author, and the demand is certainly there.
I had no idea a graphic novel was in the works until I saw it in the new adult fiction section of the library! I was curious about whether it would be sort a mostly musical adaptation with some book elements, or strictly a book adaptation. For anyone considering reading it, I personally loved it, and it is a faithful adaptation of the novel! (It’s part 1, though, so it ends after the City of Emeralds section.)
While I personally have no issue with the more adult elements of the novel, I was (like I said) a bit too young for it at first. The graphic novel stays true to the original novel while omitting a couple of the more shocking scenes like the philosophy club and the doubly-endowed puppet. (The puppet show about Frex is still there.) I am very anti-censorship, but as the graphic novel obviously has much less text than the novel, not everything could make it in regardless, and I think these scenes—while certainly memorable—are not that essential to the plot lol.
The only major omission I can recall that I’d consider detrimental to the story is the lion cub scene??? Seems odd to include the scene with the antlers (referencing the Magic Powder of Life and the Gump from The Marvelous Land of Oz), but not the lion cub scene. The former was likely included because it’s when Fiyero is introduced, but I think anyone would’ve been fine with a few extra pages to get the lion cub scene. I also missed the implications that Elphaba is intersex in this version, but oh, well.
Anyway, I am always trying to get more people (adults) to give Maguire’s book a chance, and I think the graphic novel is overall a great middle ground in terms of maturity for teens and up!
The only change that I thought was a little odd, although not necessarily bad, was that Fiyero’s tattoos were stars instead of diamonds, and they were on his back instead of his chest and face. I’m not sure what the reason for that was. But at least he isn’t white!
I’d love to hear your thoughts on the graphic novel if you’ve read it, and I’m excited to read part 2!