So, how do you hold the pro controller?
This seems like a stupid question, but I'm being genuine here.
I've recently dug up my pro controller so I could have something wireless for my PC, and it's actually working way better than my cheapo wired Switch controller. I love the feel of the buttons and the joysticks, and I actually really like the two sticks on the top layout.
The problem is I have no clue how to hold this thing! I've looked it up online and I can only find comments about the gamepad making peoples fingers cramp, or how ergonomic the pro controller is, and it's making me feel like I'm an idiot for not being able to use this controller for longer than 30 minutes without my hands feeling stiff.
My main problem is that it feels like the grips simply aren't big enough. If I go for a grip that only has the pointer finger for both the buttons and the triggers, my pinky and ring fingers can comfortably curl around the grip, but that leaves my middle fingers hovering right where the back of the controller flattens out. I can straighten out my middle fingers flat against the back, or have them curl around nothing and just sorta float there, and either one of those really starts to feel uncomfortable after a while.
It gets even more confusing when I use a grip that puts both a pointer and middle finger on top of the controller so I can use the bumpers and triggers at the same time. The two options there are having the whole controller slip down, putting my pinky and ring fingers on that flat back and making it really hard to press the buttons, or to just push my hands together and use the force of my palms to hold it up with my pinky and ring fingers free floating like how my middle fingers were with the first grip. This moves a lot of pressure into my palms and generally becomes hard to use after a short amount of play.
Is it simply too small for my hands, or am I missing something? I've seen fairly unanimous praise for this thing and I am so so inclined to agree because the rest of using it is a joy, but the fact that I'm having issues with something fundamental about its design makes it seem like I'm just not understanding something everyone else picked up on.
EDIT: Alright, I had to dig out my pretty iffy $20 PowerA wired switch pro controller again, but I can confirm there is no skill issue involved (which would explain the lukewarm responses I've been getting). Turns out, the Wii U pro controller is just ergonomically poor! Here, I'll walk you through the comparison images. Outside of the images where the logo is obvious, you can tell which is which by the triggers: The Wii U pro controller has the smaller more inset triggers, while the $20 controller has the larger protruding triggers.

At first glance, it looks pretty neck and neck when both controllers are aligned with a straight edge, partially the reason I thought it was user error at first. The Switch one is only a hair longer than the Wii U Pro controller. So why the discomfort? Well, when you turn it around...

Yikes. Don't pay attention to lengths here, that's perspective trickery: Remember they're both supposed to be around the same size. But the Switch pro controller just has way more girth! You can also notice that the grips continue to protrude out into the underside of the triggers, unlike the Wii U pro controller, which has the grip go flush with the back of the controller before jutting out again for the triggers. The end result is...

The Wii U Pro controller has this **massive** ravine at the back. You can see that the Switch controller on the right has a fairly consistent grip length all the way up the side of the controller, while the Wii U controller tapers off immensely, creating the perfect place for your hands to uncomfortably slide into, and giving your fingers almost no support if you aren't actively wrapping them around the bottom half of the grip (which is why I described my fingers as hovering off the controller in the post proper).
This is truly unfortunate, because that $20 controller has much spongier buttons, but I guess I'll have to stick to using it for the time being and put the Wii U one back in the storage bin. I'll leave this post up so that people in the future who have the same experience I did know that they aren't crazy, this controller is just weird.