RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/wildhearthstone • … • u/itsdantexxxx

Tick lock: I think it’s time to take a serious look at this very polarizing deck

I’ll start this by saying: this is my opinion. Feel free to fill in gaps of knowledge below if you wish. Thank you. Listen, I get it. A cool new card comes out that discards the other person’s hand. Who doesn’t want to try it out? But it’s been months now, and the deck has shown to be much more than a meme. I’m in fairly high Legend (not that it matters for anything other than context), and this deck has been over half my matchups for weeks. Feel free to let me know how it does in other ranks, but to my knowledge it’s had huge waves of popularity across all ranks. I’ve played this game for many years and really try to avoid the “I hate this deck, delete it” mentality, but I’m getting close to my wits’ end with this deck.

Why I think it’s unhealthy for the game:

\-We’ve seen these decks before. It’s Wild. Cheese always exists and always will. The issue is that these types of crazy win cons usually come with extreme disadvantages that keep their win rate around meme territory. Correct me if I’m wrong, but across multiple patches over the past few months, Tick Lock has maintained a fairly high win rate across a lot of ranks, with a ton of different builds. Turns out, when the other person can’t keep a hand, the other 20 cards in your deck matter a lot less. TLDR: for a deck with such an uninteractive win con/playstyle, it’s really, really good. Both the Egg and Reno builds do great because, again, when your core game plan can basically auto-win a chunk of slower matchups, the rest of the deck matters a lot less.

\-I don’t believe I’m even the first to say this, but this deck is fairly meta-warping in a very unhealthy way. We’ve seen true control/slow decks almost completely evaporate from the meta, or fall off in play rate. At first I thought aggro was just too good. But as time went on, that really hasn’t seemed to be the case. Clone Mech has fallen off a ton, Discard is played here and there, and aggro overall seems pretty balanced atm. Okay, so combo? Well, also no. Razorscale, the 3-spell-cost-more cards, and the other disruption in Wild actually keep people away from Auctioneer cheese surprisingly well. So what’s keeping basically any deck that isn’t trying to smash your face in by turn 5/6 from playing the game? The answer seems pretty obvious to me: the deck that deletes your hand 5 times over. I really believe this deck is stopping a ton of healthy variety from existing: Reno Pala, slower Warrior decks that are definitely around as there great against aggro but still don’t see as much of, slower Shaman decks as a whole, and possibly slower midrange decks too. People have been really inventive the past few months with deckbuilding, but if you’re not winning by turn 5/6, you shouldn’t be forced into such an insane disadvantage against one deck.

\-I know changes in Wild can lead to weird consequences, which is why they’re mainly avoided. Another big bad can always take something’s place. But I really don’t think that’s the case here. Tick Lock’s unfavorable matchups are mostly decks that kill you very fast, which already have plenty of counters, and some Druid decks that can ramp and play big threats quickly. Again, not exactly some lurking meta tyrant. Then there’s the famed best deck in Wild, Quest Demon Hunter. The demon hunter is favored, a lot. But there you go. It’s already good. If anything, not having this matchup might allow more decks that counter Demon Hunter to emerge too. What is Tick Lock really keeping at bay? 100 armor Warrior? Reno Priest? Reno Paladin? Warsong? Sulfuras Warrior? If those are the decks we’re afraid of coming back, then what are we even doing here?

\-Lastly, I’ll mention playstyle and precedent. Playstyle: I would definitely categorize this as a playstyle issue. You simply shouldn’t be punished because, completely out of your control, your win condition happened to be in your opening mulligan in a slower deck. It feels bad and has very little counterplay besides Finley, which means you may not see those cards again for a long time anyway. A lot of healthy slower decks also need multiple pieces to function. You basically sit there drawing one card at a time, hoping it’s the card you need to potentially swing the game back in your favor, while waiting for your hand to be deleted another 3-6 times and eventually another 6 cards from your deck through Symphony.

\-Precedent: let’s talk about Hostage Mage and the Rommath nerf. Why did it happen? Hostage Mage was, across almost all ranks besides higher Legend, at best a Tier 3 deck. It was pretty easy to disrupt with Rat and Theo because it ran very few minions, and taking ETC or Rommath could ruin the deck most of the time. It had a pretty meh play rate, was never a meta tyrant, and had hard counters. Reno Shaman and other disruption decks destroyed it. Yet it was basically deleted off the face of the earth. And unlike Tick Lock, it had quite a high skill cap, which is partly why it never really left Tier 3. So why? Its playstyle was deemed bad for the game. That’s fine. But then what’s stopping Tick Lock from getting the same treatment? The play pattern is pretty similar in some ways: sitting there drawing one card after another, hoping it’s finally what you need, while waiting for your hand to be deleted again. Except Tick Lock is actually good. And popular. TLDR: just food for thought. If Hostage Mage was way less popular, had a higher skill cap, lower win rate, hard-counter matchups, etc., but still got deleted because of its playstyle, why shouldn’t Tick Lock be looked at under the same logic when it’s quite the opposite in a lot of those regards besides playstyle?

\-All in all, I know I’m not the first person to think this, and I’m surprised this sub isn’t more on the “delete the deck” train haha. But I guess Thief Priest is too big a distraction atm :P (Please don’t mention that deck on this post. There are plenty of posts to add your disdain for that deck if you have it.)

\-Feel free to share thoughts below. I really just want to enjoy Hearthstone again. Everything else feels pretty fair at the moment. Matchups against this deck just feel like a non-game. They either delete your cards, or you smash their face in.

— 0